Association between intraoperative cerebral microembolic signals and postoperative neuropsychological deficit: comparison between patients with cardiac valve replacement and patients with coronary artery bypass grafting
- Departments of Neurology, Psychosomatic Medicine and Surgery, Rikshospitalet, The National Hospital, University of Oslo, N 0027, Norway
- Dr SK Brækken, Department of Neurology, Ullevål Hospital, 0407 Oslo, Norway. Telephone 0047 22118650; fax 0047 23015949.
- Received 5 November 1997
- Revised 2 March 1998
- Accepted 19 March 1998
OBJECTIVES To examine the association between intraoperative cerebral microembolic signals (MES) and postoperative neuropsychological deficit in patients with valve replacement (VR) and patients with coronary artery bypass grafting (CABG).
METHODS Neuropsychological examination (10 tests) was performed 1–2 days before and 2 months after surgery (VR (n=26) and CABG (n=14)). The intraoperative number of cerebral MES were monitored from the right middle cerebral artery using transcranial Doppler.
RESULTS A higher number of cerebral MES were detected in VR patients with neurological deficit (6/26) compared with those without deficit (20/26) (MES median number 2083 v645, p=0.04). No such difference was found in patients with CABG (2/14v 12/14) (MES median number 50 v 112, p=0.2).
CONCLUSION A high number of MES were detected in patients with VR with neuropsychological deficit. In patients with CABG with such a deficit, a low number of MES were detected. This difference in number may be explained by relatively more gaseous emboli in the first and more solid in the second. However, the results in the patients with CABG should be interpreted with caution due to the few patients in this subgroup.
Neuropsychological deficit is experienced in 30% of patients examined 2 months after cardiopulmonary bypass (CPB) surgery.1 2 The functions most often affected are concentration, memory, learning, and the speed of mental and visuomotor responses.2
The aetiology of neuropsychological dysfunction after CPB is unresolved and is probably multifactorial. Two of the main hypotheses are that the decline in performance is due to microemboli entering the cerebral circulation and/or episodes of reduced cerebral perfusion pressure during surgery.
Recent clinical studies have suggested that neurological3and neuropsychological4 5 performance after CPB surgery is related to the intraoperative number of cerebral microembolic signals (MES). The aim of this study was to determine the association between intraoperative cerebral MES and decline in postoperative neuropsychological performance after valve replacement (VR) and coronary artery bypass grafting (CABG), which are the two most frequent types of CPB surgery.
Material and methods
Patients referred for VR or CABG were included in the study after giving informed consent. The following patient categories were excluded: (1) unstable angina pectoris, (2) age>70 years, (3) a history or clinical findings suggesting cerebrovascular or neurological disease, (4)>50% stenosis or occlusion of a precerebral carotid or vertebral artery or major intracranial artery assessed by Doppler examination, (5) metabolic or immunological disease, and (6) non-fluency in the Norwegian language.
Valve replacement (VR) group
Twenty seven patients, 21 men and six women, received mechanical bileaflet valves (Carbomedics).
Coronary artery bypass grafting (CABG) group
Fourteen men, of whom two had two and 12 had three vessel disease.
The alphastat strategy was applied during bypass, various membrane oxygenators, and non-pulsative Gambro roller pumps, and moderate hypothermia (32°C) were used in all patients.
TRANSCRANIAL DOPPLER MONITORING
Doppler examination of the right middle cerebral artery (MCA) was performed from five minutes before cannulation of the aorta until after decannulation, when closure of the sternum was initiated. The examination was performed with a TC 2000S (Nicolet/EME) (386 computer) with 128 point colour coded FFT. The sample volume was fixed at 10 mm and the sweep was kept constant and corresponded with a time window overlap in the range between 50% and 65%. A 2 MHz flat monitoring probe was used for monitoring the MCA at a depth of 48–56 mm. All Doppler findings were recorded on videotape (Panasonic AG 7355, Matsushita Electrical Industrial) for off line analysis.
The MES were counted both by an observer using the identification criteria of the consensus committee6 and automatically using a specially designed software (RB 11).7 The observer assessed the signals according to their sound, duration, appearance on the monitor, and the presence or absence of obvious artefact causes during the registration. When the automatic system and the observer disagreed, the observer’s assessment was used for further analysis. We have previously found a 94% sensitivity between software and observer. During periods with a very high number of MES, observer counting was impossible and only the RB 11 software was used. This program identifies MES as an enhanced power ratio of at least 3 dB and duration<300 ms. The number of MES are presented as the total median number of MES per operation.
All patients underwent a neuropsychological examination 1–2 days before, and 2 months after surgery. The neuropsychological tests were modelled on the battery developed by Newman2 (table 1). Five of the tests were used for a limited screening in patients with VR during the first week after surgery (table 1). Except for the brief postoperative assessment, administration of the tests was performed blinded to the type of surgery and the number of MES. All neuropsychological tests were scored blinded for this information.
Neuropsychological deficit was defined according to the criteria proposed by Newman.2 A deterioration ⩾1 SD unit for all preoperative scores in all patients in a test was defined as a neuropsychological impairment in one test. For an impairment to indicate neuropsychological deficit, it had to occur in two or more different tests.
CLINICAL NEUROLOGICAL EXAMINATION
A clinical neurological examination was carried out at each neuropsychological examination.
The statistical analysis was based both on two independent groups of patients (VR (n=26) and CABG (n=14)) and two outcome variables, neuropsychological deficit 3–5 days and 2 months after surgery. The neuropsychological outcome variables were dichotomised. Mann-Whitney non-parametric test was used to compare groups of patients and the paired t test when matched data were analysed. The following variables were analysed to detect a possible association with neurological deficit: patient’s age, duration of education, preoperative New York Heart Association (NYHA) functional class, left ventricular ejection fraction (EF), aortic cross clamping time, minimal nasopharyngeal temperature during CPB, CPB time, the number of MES, and respirator time. Statistical analysis was performed with the Epi Info version 5.01A (Center of Disease Control, Atlanta, USA).
There were no significant differences between the two groups for age, years of education, minimal nasopharyngeal temperature, or NYHA class. Ejection fraction was lower in the CABG group and the cross clamping and cardiopulmonary bypass times were longer in the patients with VR (p<0.05).
One patient in the VR group died 6 weeks postoperatively due to cardiogenic shock after dissection of an aortic aneurysm and did not therefore complete the postoperative evaluation.
The following neurological abnormalities—mental confusion, mild hemiparesis, unilaterally increased tendon reflexes, and primitive reflexes—were found in six (29%) of the patients at the early and in seven (18%) of the patients at the late postoperative examination (CABG n=4, VR n=3). There was no association between new clinical neurological abnormalities and cerebral MES (p=0.8, p=0.9 and p=0.09 respectively).
Early postoperative assessment
Five patients with VR refused to participate. Neuropsychological deficit was detected in 14 (67%) (median two tests, range 2–5) of the 21 VR patients who completed the examination 3–5 days after surgery. These 14 patients had a lower preoperative score in WAIS picture completion (WAIS D) (mean 15 (SD 3) v mean 18 (SD 2), p=0.03), but not in WAIS vocabulary (WAIS V) and Raven coloured progressive matrices (Raven CPM) compared with those without deficit. A higher number of MES were found in the 14 patients with deficit (median 1155), compared with those without (median 226) (p=0.03) (table2).
Late postoperative assessment
Valve replacement group—Neuropsychological deficit was found in six of the 26 patients (23%) (median two tests, range 2–3) on examination 2 months postoperatively. A lower preoperative score in Raven CPM (27 (SD 4) v 31 (SD 4), p=0.04), but not in WAIS D or WAIS V was found in those with deficit compared with those without. A higher number of MES were found in the six patients with deficit (median 2083, range 251–4541) compared with the 20 patients without such deficit (median 645, range 78–3074, p=0.04, table 2).
CABG group—Neuropsychological deficit was found in two of the 14 patients (14%) on examination 2 months after surgery. These two patients had a lower median number of MES (median 50, range 32–67) compared with those without deficit (median 112, range 19–799, p=0.2, table 2). No difference in preoperative scores in WAIS D, WAIS V, or Raven CPM was found between the patients with and those without neuropsychological deficit.
ASSOCIATION BETWEEN CLINICAL NEUROLOGICAL DEFICIT AND NEUROPSYCHOLOGICAL DEFICIT
At the early examination, four (19%) patients had both neurological deficit and neuropsychological deficit. Two months after surgery none of the patients had both.
VR and CABG differed with regard to the number of intraoperative cerebral MES and their time of occurrence.8 In the present study VR and CABG patients also differed with regard to the association between cerebral MES and neuropsychological deficit. A higher number of MES was detected in VR patients with neuropsychological deficit. During VR, most MES were detected as the heart regained effective ejection.8 These MES are assumed to be reflections from air bubbles leaving the heart and entering the cerebral circulation. This is supported by a transoesophageal echocardiography study which showed retained air in the left side of the heart or the pulmonary veins before effective ejection.9
The highest number of MES during CABG were found during clamping and declamping and the period when the aorta was cross clamped.8 10 Two previous studies4 5performed in patients with CABG reported that neuropsychological deficit 8 weeks after surgery was associated with a higher number of intraoperative cerebral MES. However, we found a low number of MES in patients with CABG and neuropsychological deficit. This result should be interpreted with caution, due to the few patients in this subgroup. However, CABG patients may have a relatively higher number of solid emboli than VR patients. This is supported by a recent study where the number of emboli detected by TCD and transeosophagal echocardiography arising with clamp placement and release during CABG, was correlated with the severity of aortic atherosclerosis.10
As previously reported,11 we found a relation between advanced age and poorer neuropsychological outcome. The mechanism by which age increases neuropsychological deficit is unknown. Advanced age was not found to have any effect on the cerebral blood flow (CBF) response to changes in mean arterial pressure or on the coupling between CBF and cerebral metabolic rate for oxygen.12Increasing atherosclerosis with asymptomatic cerebrovascular disease is the most commonly proposed explanation for the postoperative decline in neuropsychological performance with advancing age. We found some indication that patients with postoperative neuropsychological impairment had lower preoperative function. This association was only found for one of three preoperative measures, and it was not consistent for the short term and long term outcome. It is reasonable to assume that patients with lower premorbid intellectual functioning may have a higher risk for postoperative cognitive impairment. However, this could not be shown in our study as patients were selected on strict medical criteria and before surgery were intellectually normal.
In conclusion, this study has shown a positive association between the intraoperative number of MES and postoperative deficit in patients with VR but not in patients with CABG.
The study was supported by The Norwegian Council on Cardiovascular Diseases.