Statistics from Altmetric.com
Lead has been used by humans as long as recorded history for various purposes ranging from jewellery to weapons and construction materials, paints, and pigment manufacture. Lead colic was known to ancient physicians since the time of Hippocrates, but encephalopathy was first described as late as 1925; it is especially common in children. Here we report a rare case of lead encephalopathy associated with ataxia in a 30 year old battery plate manufacturer.
He had been working for the past 12 years in a factory making battery plates. He presented with history of abnormal behaviour and unsteadiness of gait for 8 days accompanied by colicky abdominal pain and paraesthesiae in the legs. Later the patient started behaving abnormally; he shouted irrelevantly, became violent, and refused to recognise relatives. He was treated with antipsychotic medication which quietened him. Two days later he had difficulty in walking. His gait was unsteady and speech was incoherent.
Enquiry disclosed two earlier episodes of abdominal pain with abnormal behaviour in the past year which responded to treatment, the details of which were not available. Two other factory workers had also had episodic abnormal behaviour but were not available for interrogation. There was no history of fever or symptoms suggestive of raised intracranial pressure, seizures, or focal motor or sensory deficits. The patient denied consumption of alcohol on a regular basis.
On admission the patient was afebrile, pulse 82/min, BP 116/76 mm Hg. There was mild pallor and a suspicious bluish grey discoloration of the gums. He was conscious and oriented, but extremely restless. He was totally anarthric. A detailed evaluation of higher functions was not possible due to the restlessness and anarthria, but from the limited evaluation, comprehension appeared intact. There was no evidence of hallucinations or delusions. The optic fundi were normal. There was no nystagmus and the lower cranial nerves were normal except for slow movements of the tongue.
Motor system examination disclosed no significant weakness. There were prominent cerebellar signs in the form of truncal ataxia, impaired finger to nose and knee-heel tests, and dysdiadochokinesia. There was no tremor and no sensory deficits. Deep tendon reflexes were normal. Both plantar reflexes were extensor. There was no neck stiffness.
The history of abdominal colic and behavioural abnormalities in a person working with battery plates and also of similar complaints in coworkers, raised a clinical suspicion of lead toxicity.
Blood lead concentration estimated on the next day was 89 μg/dl (normal range 10–15 μg/dl), which confirmed lead toxicity. The patient had hypochromic microcytic anaemia (Hb 8.3 g). There was no basophilic stippling. Urine examination was normal and negative for porphyrins. There was no azotaemia (BUN 10.0 mg/dl, serum creatinine 1.0 mg/dl), Serum electrolytes were normal Na 133 (normal 132-–144) meq/l, K 4.6 (3.6–5.0) meq/l, Cl 98 (96–108) meq/l, Ca 10.0 (9-ll) mg/dl. Liver function tests were normal.
T2 weighted MRI disclosed bilateral hyperintense lesions in both thalami (figure). The EEG did not show any focal or background rhythm abnormalities. Peripheral nerve conduction studies were within normal limits.
The patient was treated with mannitol and intravenous fluids. Oral chelation therapy was started with penicillamine on day 2. EDTA or dimercaprol could not be instituted due to unavailability. The patient showed significant improvement in behaviour, and speech returned by day 3 of admission, although extremely slurred. The unsteadiness and dysarthria improved steadily until discharge 2 weeks later. Repeat estimation of lead concentration at discharge was 64 μg/dl. The patient showed complete neurological recovery on follow up 6 months after discharge. He was able to perform his routine duties, but decided to look for a different job. A repeat blood lead concentration was 52 g/dl.
Lead intoxication most often occurs in 1 to 3 year old children due to chewing of lead paint. Acute encephalopathy is a serious complication in children, which can be fatal or leave permanent neurological sequelae.1
Lead toxicity is much less common in adults. It is mainly an occupational hazard due to inhalation of lead fumes or physical contact with lead in processes that require remelting of lead, such as painting, lead smelting, pottery glazing, and storage battery manufacture. The emissions of vehicles using leaded petroleum is a recognised source of environmental pollution in urban areas.2 The usual manifestations of lead poisoning in adults are colic, anaemia, and peripheral motor neuropathy. Encephalopathy is rare. Whitfield et al (1972) reported the largest series of 23 adults with lead encephalopathy; all these followed consumption of illicit liquor contaminated by lead (moonshine).3 Ten of these patients had altered sensorium; 18 of them had seizures. Other symptoms included dizziness, syncope, disorientation, and blindness. One had papilloedema. None of the patients had ataxia. Ataxia was a prominent feature in our patient and has been described as a feature of lead encephalopathy in children.1 4 This could be secondary to raised intracranial pressure or to direct involvement of the cerebellum. Lead acts as a cellular toxin by inhibiting mitochondrial respiration. The increased resistance of the adult to encephalopathy and ataxia is believed to be due to the capacity of the mature brain to sequestrate lead away from its mitochondrial site of action within the cerebral and cerebellar neurons.5
T2 weighted MRI in our patient disclosed hyperintensities in both thalami (figure). Schroter et al reported high signal intensities in the periventricular white matter, basal ganglia, insula, posterior thalamus, and pons.6
Our patient did not have basophilic stippling of peripheral red blood cells. Basophilic stippling of erythrocytes is reported in 91% of patients by Whitfield et al,3 but was seen in only 40% of cases reported by Greengard et al.4 It is more pronounced in the bone marrow than in the peripheral blood7 and may be missed unless carefully looked for.
The extent of clinical recovery was out of proportion to the decline in blood concentrations. Free erythrocyte protoporphyrin and the urinary concentrations of γ-aminolevulinic acid (ALA) or coproporphyrin are better clinical correlates of lead toxicity, rather than estimations of blood lead concentration. In our patient only the urinary porphobilinogen could be estimated.
Severe medical illness, alcohol, dehydration, and emotional stress are known to precipitate symptoms of lead poisoning, but we were unable to identify any such factors in our patient.
To summarise, frank encephalopathy due to lead intoxication has become increasingly rare in adults. We report a patient with lead encephalopathy who presented with behaviour problems and cerebellar ataxia.
If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.