Article Text


Clinical features and outcomes in patients with non-acoustic cerebellopontine angle tumours
  1. Connor L Malluccia,
  2. Victoria Warda,
  3. A Simon Carneyb,
  4. Gerard M O’Donoghueb,
  5. Iain Robertsona
  1. aDepartment of Neurosurgery, bDepartment of Otolaryngology—Head and Neck Surgery, Queen’s Medical Centre, Nottingham, UK
  1. Mr G M O’Donoghue, Department of Otolaryngology—Head and Neck Surgery, Queen’s Medical Centre, Nottingham NG7 2UH, UK. Telephone 0044 115 924 9924; fax 0044 115 970 9748.


OBJECTIVES Non-acoustic tumours of the cerebellopontine angle differ from vestibular schwannomas in their prevalence, clinical features, operative management, and surgical outcome. These features were studied in patients presenting to the regional neuro-otological unit.

METHODS A retrospective analysis of clinical notes identified 42 patients with non-acoustic tumours of the cerebellopontine angle. Data were extracted regarding presenting clinical features, histopathological data after surgical resection, surgical morbidity and mortality, and clinical outcome (mean 32 months follow up).

RESULTS The study group comprised 25 meningiomas (60%), 12 epidermoid cysts/cholesteatomata (28%), and five other tumours. In patients with meningiomas, symptoms differed considerably from patients presenting with vestibular schwannomas. Cerebellar signs were present in 52% and hearing loss in only 68%. Twenty per cent of patients had hydrocephalus at the time of diagnosis. After surgical resection, normal facial nerve function was preserved in 75% of cases. In the epidermoid group, fifth, seventh, and eighth nerve deficits were present in 42%, 33%, and 66% respectively. There were no new postoperative facial palsies. There were two recurrences (17%) requiring reoperation. Overall, there were two perioperative deaths from pneumonia and meningitis.

CONCLUSIONS Patients with non-acoustic lesions of the cerebellopontine angle often present with different symptoms and signs from those found in patients with schwannomas. Hearing loss is less prevalent and cerebellar signs and facial paresis are more common as presenting features. Hydrocephalus is often present in patients presenting with cerebellopontine angle meningiomas. Non-acoustic tumours can usually be resected with facial nerve preservation.

  • cerebellopontine angle
  • brain tumour
  • meningioma

Statistics from

Tumours of the cerebellopontine angle account for 8%–10% of all intracranial tumours. Acoustic neuromas (vestibular schwannomas), arising from the neurilemmal junction of the vestibular nerve, account for between 80%–90% of these tumours.1-4 Other sources of tumour in this region include epidermal cell rests (giving rise to epidermoid cysts, dermoid cysts, and cholesteatomata), arachnoid villi/granulations and the meninges (meningiomas, arachnoid cysts), primary intrinsic lesions (gliomas, ependymomas), fat cells (lipomas), tumours extending from the cranial base (for example, glomus jugulare tumours), vascular lesions (haemangiopericytomas), and secondary tumours.1 2

The relation of each of these tumours to the bone of the cranial base varies greatly and has implications for surgical management. Understanding the precise relation of each tumour to the adjacent neural, vascular, and sensory structures is critically important if the best functional outcome is to be achieved after surgical resection.1 Accurate preoperative diagnosis of tumour type is therefore of the utmost importance in planning the optimal management strategy for each patient.5-8

In addition, accurate diagnosis enables informed discussion with patients about the natural history of the untreated disease compared with the potential risks of surgical and non-surgical management.

The purpose of this study was to review the pattern of presentation of a consecutive series of non-acoustic tumours of the cerebellopontine angle, to assess the ability to predict the histological diagnosis preoperatively, and to analyse the outcome of treatment.

Patients and methods

Patients were identified from a continually updated database of all cerebellopontine angle tumours presenting to the combined otoneurosurgical regional unit in Nottingham. Data were recorded retrospectively from clinical notes and radiological imaging including CT and MRI (the second including both conventional T1 and T2 images with and without contrast). More recently, MRI with constructive interference in the steady state9 (CISS) images has also been available.

The following data were recorded: age, sex, histological review, duration of symptoms, clinical symptoms and signs, preoperative and postoperative radiological investigations, surgical approach, complications, and subsequent progress.


Forty two patients were identified who had been treated by this department between 1980 and 1996. There were seven men and 35 women, with a median age of 54 years. Median follow up postsurgery was 3 years (range 8 months-14 years).

Patients with meningiomas (n=25) comprised most of the group, followed by patients with epidermoid cysts/cholesteatomata (n=12). Other lesions included two haemangiopericytomas, a metastatic adenocarcinoma, and an ependymoma.


In our series, there were 25 patients with meningiomas, 21 women and four men with a median age of 55 years. Median duration of symptoms was 12 months. About half the patients had signs of cerebellar ataxia at presentation (table), with only a third presenting with subjective hearing loss. Two patients presented with facial pain, three with facial numbness, and four with symptoms of raised intracranial pressure. Only three patients had tinnitus on direct questioning, but tinnitus was not a major presenting symptom. On pure tone audiometry, 68% had evidence of asymmetric (>10 dB four tone average) sensorineural hearing impairment.

Clinical features and operative complications

Radiological work up included CT in 21 and MRI in 16 patients. In all 20 patients operated on with available histology and one in whom pathology was obtained postmortem, the radiological reports predicted a likely diagnosis of meningioma in all 21 patients giving 100% predictive accuracy. Five patients (20%), had hydrocephalus at presentation.

Surgical management of meningiomas

Twenty patients went on to have surgical resections of which 13 (65%) were complete and seven (35%) were subtotal. The surgical approach was retrosigmoid in all but one patient, in whom a translabyrinthine approach was used. Two patients who were elderly had ventriculoperitoneal shunts only. Two patients with small tumours are being followed up with regular periodical scanning and the remaining patient presented in extremis with hydrocephalus and coma and died before any surgical intervention.

Complications of cerebellopontine angle meningioma surgery

Complications are shown in the table. In 75% the facial nerve was spared, in three patients there was partial recovery at follow up, reaching House and Brackman10 grades 1 or 2 and in only two patients were permanent unrecoverable (grade 3 or more) facial palsies recorded. Four patients had their lower cranial nerves (ninth and 10th) affected with diminished gag reflex and/or swallow. In one patient a long term tracheostomy was required. Other complications included third and 12th nerve palsies which recovered spontaneously, a postoperative haematoma that required emergency evacuation, and four wound CSF leaks which stopped spontaneously or with only a further suture on the ward.

There were two postoperative deaths. Both died in the month after surgery. The first patient, requiring the emergency evacuation of postoperative haematoma, died of aspiration pneumonia partially attributable to poor gag and swallow reflexes secondary to ninth/10th nerve palsies after surgery. The second patient succumbed to postoperative infection and ventriculitis and died from systemic sepsis.

Follow up

There have been no recurrences in patients with planned complete resections and in those with known subtotal resections, the residuum is being followed up with regular imaging but there have been no episodes of tumour progression requiring reoperation to date.


There were 12 patients with epidermoid cysts/cholesteatomata, together comprising 29% of the total group. The median age was 42 years with a female:male ratio of 5:1. Median duration of symptoms was 24 months (table). Symptomatic hearing loss as a presenting symptom was present in 50% of patients (66% had diminished hearing on formal testing). Thirty two per cent and 42% of patients respectively presented with facial nerve and trigeminal nerve involvement. Other presenting symptoms and signs included four patients with cerebellar signs, one with dysphagia and one with diplopia. Only one patient had hydrocephalus and again none had tinnitus as a main presenting symptom.

Radiological investigation included 10 CT scans and nine MRI scans. The suggested radiological diagnosis in this group compared with histological diagnosis was 88% accurate.


Eight of the patients went on to have surgical resections of which five were complete excisions and three were subtotal. Four patients with small tumours are being followed up prospectively with interval scanning. The approach was retrosigmoid in six and translabyrinthine in two patients.


There have been no new facial palsies; two patients had a diminished gag reflex postoperatively although neither have required tracheostomy. There was one CSF leak, which was successfully managed with further suturing to the wound. There were no infective complications and no mortality in this group of patients. Postoperative hearing was unchanged (<10 dB 4 tone average) in all patients undergoing non-destructive approaches.

Follow up

With a median follow up of 58 months there have been two recurrences in the operated group, both patients in whom it was known that subtotal excisions had been performed. Both required reoperation due to the symptomatic regrowth of residual tumour.

The four patients being treated conservatively show no tumour progression to date.

Miscellaneous tumours

These included two haemangiopericytomas, one metastatic adenocarcinoma, one ependymoma, and one lesion of unknown histology. Four of these have had surgery, with no recurrences in the two patients with haemangiopericytomas. Both patients with ependymoma and adenocarcinoma have since re-presented with metastases at extracranial sites.


Acoustic neuromas remain by far the most prevalent lesion to be found in the cerebellopontine angle.4 Meningiomas are the second most common tumour to be found in this site, accounting for exactly 6.5% of all cases in two separate British series.2 11 Meningiomas accounted for 60% of our series, more than the 33% and 32% reported respectively in the London11 and Cambridge2 series. These differences may reflect local referral practices. Epidermoid cysts and cholesteatomata are often included together in reported series and if we combine numbers of the two patient groups, they represent 29% of total numbers, more in keeping with the proportion found in other series.1 2

The clinical features of haemangiopericytomas, metastases, and other rare lesions of the cerebellopontine angle have been well documented by other workers,12-18 and their rarity does not allow meaningful comparisons to be made about prevalence rates.

In this study, as in previous reports, non-acoustic tumours of the cerebellopontine angle are more likely to present with cerebellar symptoms than schwannomas.2 13 The most common complaint was of unsteadiness or falling persistently to one side and was accompanied by clinically apparent ataxia. However, other symptoms associated with cerebellar dysfunction (for example, intention tremor and nystagmus) were uncommon findings. The latter infrequency in our series is a marked difference from other workers’ findings with similar numbers of patients presenting with ataxia.3 It has been reported that these symptoms are often considered mild11 and this would seem to be borne out by our study. Those patients who presented primarily with cerebellar signs experienced symptoms for a lengthy period (longer than the mean) before diagnosis.

Cranial nerve palsies were the main source of prediagnosis morbidity with sensorineural hearing loss being the most common presenting symptom and sign. However, compared with acoustic neuroma series hearing loss is much less prevalent in keeping with other experiences.1 8 19 Formal preoperative and postoperative assessment of hearing in this group is essential and will not only have a bearing on the choice of surgical approach adopted but will help clinicians to optimise resection techniques to maximise the chance of some hearing preservation.

Trigeminal nerve symptoms are more prominent in non-acoustic lesions1 8 and particularly with epidermoid cysts, are more likely to cause trigeminal pain than altered sensation.20 This is one symptom that can be gratifyingly improved by surgery.

We were surprised by the relative infrequency of reported tinnitus, (12%) which has generally been found in association with hearing loss in other series2 11 19 although others have also pointed out that it is also an infrequent complaint in non-acoustic cerebellopontine angle lesions.1 We have found no cases of true rotatory vertigo such as have been reported by other workers.11 19

Overall symptomatology is still dependent on tumour size and the exact location of the lesion and we agree with others that there are not enough clinical differences in presentation to allow preoperative differentiation from acoustic tumours on history and examination alone.1 2 There are, however, often relevant clinical clues that should alert the clinician that the lesion may well be non-acoustic2 and this may be of importance if the radiological findings are inconclusive.

Various approaches have been shown to be feasible in resecting tumours in the posterior fossa and have been well reviewed.21 Most of our cases were exposed through a retrosigmoid approach. This has afforded good visualisation and allowed resection of the tumour without recourse to excessive retraction. However, for the petroclival meningiomas a transpetrosal approach has recently proved to us to have major advantages. In the patient with no prospect of useful postoperative hearing, a translabyrinthine approach may be appropriate especially for the tumours involving the internal auditory meatus11 although it must always be remembered that hearing may occasionally improve or even return to normal after the resection of non-acoustic cerebellopontine angle tumours22 23 and destructive approaches must therefore be used selectively.

Despite using an approach that offers optimal exposure, certain clival meningiomas and extensive epidermoids are difficult to remove in their entirety without subjecting the patient to unacceptable morbidity.1 Other studies have also included patients with incomplete excisions.1 8 In the case of an extensive epidermoid cyst, the tumour may have extensive adherent capsule extensions folding around important structures.1 Clival meningiomas may be adherent to the brain stem or may envelop arteries or nerves which need to be preserved. Our study reinforces the view of others1 that, despite a relatively short follow up, due to the biology of these tumours, incomplete excision can still afford good lifestyle with minimal morbidity for years with no essential requirement for further surgery. If repeat surgery is required, it may be at very infrequent intervals, often as long as a decade apart.1

Because of the implications for surgical management, it is essential that non-acoustic tumours of the cerebellopontine angle are correctly diagnosed preoperatively.2 Fortunately, with the availability of high quality MRI, an accurate diagnosis can be made in most cases1 although in one recent series, 25% of cerebellopontine angle meningiomas were radiologically thought to be vestibular schwannomas and the exact nature of atypical tumours was only demonstrated in 67% of cases.8 Computed tomography does not always disclose the nature of an atypical cerebellopontine angle lesion20 and there is no doubt that MRI is now the radiological investigation of choice.1 2 Even with contrast enhanced MRI, small lesions may still be radiologically similar to schwannomas24 and complex new imaging techniques such as CISS may be necessary to show the true nature and anatomy of a non-acoustic lesion.9 We would recommend the use of CISS MRI sequences when there is any doubt as to the exact nature of a cerebellopontine angle mass. A detailed discussion on the radiological diagnosis of non-acoustic tumours is beyond the scope of this paper and has been well covered by other authors.1 2 25-28

Whereas vestibular schwannomas rarely recur after complete resection, this is not the case for other cerebellopontine angle lesions.8 Ten to 13% of patients with cerebellopontine angle meningiomas develop recurrent disease, thought to be due to inadequate bone removal at the time of initial surgery or the persistence of tumour within the dura.8 11 Although some series report good results after the resection of epidermoid cysts/cholesteatomata,8 other workers have found that they are notoriously prone to recurrence29 30 and long term follow up is essential. Rarer lesions have an even higher rate of recurrence and regular follow up and rescanning of patients with these rare tumours is essential.2


Non-acoustic tumours of the cerebellopontine angle often present with a different range of symptoms and signs to those found in patients with schwannomas. Hearing loss is less prevalent and cerebellar signs and facial paresis are more common as presenting features. Hydrocephalus is often present in patients presenting with cerebellopontine angle meningiomas.

All non-cerebellopontine angle lesions are more prone to recurrence than acoustic neuromas and long term follow up is recommended. Useful hearing can be preserved in a high proportion of cases and these rare tumours can usually be resected with preservation of facial nerve function.


View Abstract

Request permissions

If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.