OBJECTIVES To record N18 in median somatosensory evoked potentials (SEPs) for deeply comatose or brain dead patients and to demonstrate the usefulness of N18 for the diagnosis of brain death in comparison with auditory brain stem responses (ABRs) and P13/14 in median SEPs, which have been conventionally used as complementary tests for the diagnosis of brain death.
METHODS Subjects were 19 deeply comatose or brain dead patients. Thirteen recordings were performed in deeply comatose but not brain dead conditions, and 12 recordings were performed in brain death. N18 was evaluated in the CPi-C2S lead (or other scalp-C2S leads) to obtain a flat baseline.
RESULTS N18 was preserved in 12 of 13 non-brain dead comatose recordings whereas it was completely lost for all of the 12 brain death recordings. P13/14 in median SEPs was preserved for all the comatose recordings, whereas apparent P13/14-like potentials, usually of low amplitude, were seen in nine of 12 brain death recordings—that is, frequent false positives. The ABRs already showed features which were characteristic for brain death (loss of components other than wave 1 or small wave 2) for four comatose recordings, in three of which N18 was preserved. The last result not only corresponds with the fact that ABRs can evaluate pontine and midbrain functions and not medullary function, but further supports the medullary origin of N18. In the four patients followed up for the course of progression from coma to brain death, N18s preserved in normal size during the comatose state were completely lost after brain death was established.
CONCLUSIONS The N18 potential is generated by the cuneate nucleus in the medulla oblongata in the preceding studies. N18 is suggested to be a promising tool for the diagnosis of brain death because there were no false positives and rare false negatives in the present series for detecting the remaining brain stem function.
- somatosensory evoked potentials
- brain death
- cuneate nucleus
Statistics from Altmetric.com
Evoked potentials have been used as non-invasive complementary tests for the diagnosis of brain death. Among them, auditory brain stem responses (ABRs) have been the most popular.1-5 However, one drawback of ABRs is that they are generated within the pons and midbrain and do not reflect the function of the medulla oblongata, which is critical for the maintenance of vital functions such as respiration and circulation. Application of somatosensory evoked potentials (SEPs) to the diagnosis of brain death has also been investigated, mainly focusing on the P13/14 potential in median SEPs of possible brain stem origin, with limited success.2 3 6-10
N18 in median nerve SEPs is a broad negativity widely distributed over the scalp after positive far field potentials.11 There has been much controversy regarding its origin, but we recently presented an opinion that N18 is principally generated at the cuneate nucleus located in the caudal medulla oblongata.12-15 This hypothesis prompted us to evaluate the usefulness of N18 for the diagnosis of brain death. In this report, we present the first results of our study recording N18s in deeply comatose or brain dead patients, focusing on the comparison with ABRs and P13/14.
Patients and methods
Subjects were 19 deeply comatose (Glasgow coma scale score⩽6) or brain dead patients (12 men and seven women, age 20–79). Their clinical backgrounds were six with supratentorial haemorrhage, two with brain stem haemorrhage, four with subarachnoid haemorrhage, one with superior sagittal sinus thrombosis, two with brain injury, and four with brain hypoxia. Brain death was diagnosed according to the Japanese guideline,16 although the apnoea test was not usually done because the performance of a potentially invasive apnoea test for patients not intended for organ transplantation is not ethically acceptable according to the ethics committee of our university (Organ transplantation from brain dead patients was recently been allowed by law but has rarely been performed in Japan.) In this sense, there remains the theoretical possibility that the patients classified as brain dead according to our criteria excluding the apnoea test may manifest preserved respiratory function. However, we can safely assume that such cases must be very rare, because previous large series indicate that there was virtually no case in which the apnoea test disclosed masked respiratory function in patients strictly fulfilling other criteria of brain death.17 18 Moreover, the point of establishment of brain death was usually clinically definable in the present series by the ceasing of spontaneous respiration accompanied by a sudden fall in blood pressure without any circulatory cause. Recovery of spontaneous respiration was never found in such patients.
Twenty five recordings were performed for these patients, of which 13 were in deeply comatose but not brain dead conditions (Brain death was excluded by preserved spontaneous respiration in 10 recordings and by constricted and reactive pupil, decerebrate response, or involuntary facial myoclonus in three other recordings.) and 12 in brain death thus clinically defined. We repeated recordings two to four times during the course of progression from coma to brain death in four patients. Informed consent was obtained from the families of the patients.
The SEPs were recorded after median nerve stimulation at the wrist at a rate of 5 Hz. The side of stimulation was selected so that the less affected side of the brain would be stimulated when there was laterality of the lesion. Recording electrodes were placed on several points including C2S (second cervical vertebrae), CPc, and CPi (centroparietal electrodes contralateral and ipsilateral to the stimulated limb, respectively, as defined by the guideline of the American Electroencephalographic Society19), Fz, and NC (non-cephalic reference on the contralateral shoulder). Evoked potentials were amplified and filtered between 5 and 1500 Hz (−3 dB). Totals of 1000–4000 (usually 2000) responses were averaged and two averages were superimposed.
N18 was evaluated by the CPi-C2S or other scalp-C2S leads, the second being used when cortical components were lost. These derivations with C2S reference are crucial to the evaluation of N18 because they give sufficiently flat baselines which enable us to correctly identify the long lasting N18 potentials.13 14 The baseline of scalp-NC leads, which have been conventionally used to record N18, often shows a constant incline due to slow ECG artifacts (fig 1). P13/14 was evaluated by the CPc-NC or other scalp-NC leads.
N18 was judged to be preserved only when there was a definite increase over the baseline continuous from the ascending limb of the preceding positivity, which is a complex potential contributed by scalp P13/14 and upper cervical N13.20 N18 thus had a rather steep onset and reached its maximal amplitude within several milliseconds of the first upward crossing over the baseline, and then slowly returned to the baseline around 20 milliseconds. The amplitude of N18 was measured from the baseline, usually within several milliseconds of its onset as described above (fig 1). The duration of N18 was also measured although the end of N18 was sometimes difficult to define accurately. In some brain death recordings, the wave returned to baseline after the preceding positivity and then showed a slight increase over the baseline after several milliseconds (fig 2). Such a negativity was not interpreted as N18 in the present study and N18 was judged to be lost in such cases. Although we cannot completely ignore the possibility that such a delayed negativity is a delayed and depressed N18, it was so different from the typical configuration of N18 and was difficult to distinguish from a residual minimal incline of the baseline.
The ABRs were recorded after a 105 dB NHL click sound given to both ears at a rate of 13 Hz. Fz-A1 and Fz-A2 leads were recorded (Fz was substituted for Cz to spare the number of electrodes). Totals of 2000–4000 responses were averaged and two averages were superimposed.
The results are summarised in the table. N18 was definitely preserved for all but one of the comatose recordings. The only comatose recording with absent N18 was found in a patient with pontine haemorrhage, in whom involuntary facial myoclonus excluded brain death but spontaneous respiration and all the brain stem reflexes were already lost, suggesting very limited survival of brain stem function. N18 was lost for all the brain death recordings. The amplitude of N18 was 0.94 (SD 0.38) μV (range 0.43–1.67 μV) and its duration was 25.8 (SD 3.0) ms (range 21–31 ms) for 12 comatose recordings with preserved N18. N18 of the above size was always definitely identifiable because no negativity exceeding 0.1 μV over the baseline was identified directly after the preceding positivity for recordings in which N18 was judged to be lost.
P13/14 was preserved for all the comatose recordings, whereas apparent P13/14-like potential, usually of low amplitude, was definitely found for nine out of 12 brain death recordings (fig 2). N20 was already lost for most of the comatose recordings.
The ABRs in brain death recordings were either lost (nine of 12) or registered no more than wave I and small wave II, consistent with previous reports of features of ABRs in brain death.2 5However, similar ABR patterns were also found in four of 13 comatose recordings. N18 was preserved in three of four such recordings (the exception was the recording from the patient with pontine haemorrhage), from patients in whom brain death was excluded by preserved spontaneous respiration and cough reflex (two recordings) or by decerebrate response (one recording).
For all of the four patients in whom we followed the course of progression from coma to brain death, N18s preserved in normal size during the comatose state were lost after brain death was established. P13/14 was also lost after brain death was established in two of the four patients, including the example presented (fig 3). In another two patients, P13/14 greatly reduced its amplitude but was preserved in low amplitude even after brain death was established. A typical example is shown in fig 3. The patient was a 53 year old man who developed a large putaminal haemorrhage with subsequent brain herniation and secondary brain stem haemorrhage. When the first examination was performed, he was deeply comatose and all the brain stem reflexes were lost except the cough reflex, whereas spontaneous respiration was preserved. N18 was normally preserved whereas ABRs were lost except bilateral waves I and a questionable left wave II (upper part of fig 3). One hour later, his spontaneous respiration ceased and blood pressure suddenly fell without any circulatory cause, suggesting establishment of brain death. The cough reflex was also lost. Six hours later, the second examination was done, when N18 was completely lost and the ABR showed only a questionable right wave I (lower part of fig 3).
In previous attempts to diagnose brain death by SEPs, the P13/14 potential, which has been mainly attributed to the medial lemniscus, has been used to evaluate brain stem function. However, a major problem was that P13/14 was often preserved even in brain death.3 6-10 Apparent P13/14-like potentials of low amplitude were seen in nine of 12 brain death recordings also in the present series. Previous papers reporting that the “P13” components were preserved in cervicomedullary lesions must have the same relevance.22 23 Previous investigators attributed the origin of this remnant P13 to the caudalmost brain stem, foramen magnum, or high cervical cord,10 22 23 whereas we presented an opinion that it may be related to P11 and dorsal column.21 In any case, such a controversy regarding the origin and frequent preservation in brain death (frequent false positives) must have hindered a wide clinical application of P13/14 to the diagnosis of brain death24. Wagneret al 9 10 showed that nasopharyngeal recordings of P14 could correctly differentiate between non-brain dead coma and brain death, but the technical difficulty may prevent its routine application. Loss or great reduction of the P13/14 amplitude can be employed as a reliable sign of the establishment of brain death when the course progressing from coma to brain death was followed, as suggested by the present investigation and previous studies.8-10 The problem is that it is not always possible to follow such a course, but more often the patient is considered to be brain dead when the first examination is performed (seven of 12 brain death recordings for the present series). If apparent P13/14 is preserved in such cases (six of seven for the present series), even in low amplitude, it is impossible to distinguish such potentials from “true” P13/14 indicating preserved brain stem function.
The N18 potential was first described by Desmedt and Cheron11 as a long lasting negativity widely distributed over the scalp, and its generator has long been attributed to brain stem nuclei receiving collaterals from the medial lemniscus, especially the tectal nuclei at the midbrain.25 26 However, we have shown that N18 was preserved in normal size and shape for patients with medial lemniscal lesions at pontine and medullary levels12-15 whereas it was lost in patients with C1–2 dorsal column lesions.14 21 Especially, in a patient with unilateral medial medullary syndrome in whom subsequent cortical components were severely disturbed unilaterally, N18 after stimulation of the affected side had a similar size and shape to that after stimulation of the unaffected side.15 Based on these results, we concluded that at least the major part of N18 lasting around 20 ms is principally generated around the medulla oblongata.12-15 Medullary origin of N18 has also been supported by other investigators based on findings in patients with brain stem lesions27 28 or nasopharyngeal recordings.29 Intraoperative recordings in humans and direct recordings in animals showed a long lasting potential dipole around the cuneate nucleus similar to N18 in polarity and time course.30-32 Andersen et al 33 showed that in cats this second phase of the cuneate potential with ventrorostral negative polarity is generated by the primary afferent depolarisation of presynaptic terminals of the dorsal column fibres, by contrast with the first phase due to postsynaptic depolarisation of relay cells. Taking these studies into consideration, we presented an opinion that the long lasting negativity of N18 is generated at the cuneate nucleus by the mechanism of primary afferent depolarisation.12-15 Recent investigations showed special physiological characteristics of N18, such as conspicuous occlusion induced by adjacent nerve stimulation and lack of inhibition induced by vibration interference, which are compatible with primary afferent depolarisation.34 35
The cuneate nucleus is located at the caudal part of the medulla oblongata and is close to the respiratory centre at the medulla oblongata (nucleus solitarius and area reticularis superficialis ventrolateralis36). Therefore, N18 is expected to be an indicator of function of the medulla oblongata, especially for the state of vital centres close by.
The present results support this idea. N18 was preserved for all but one non-brain dead recording, whereas it was never found in patients judged to be brain dead. In this sense, N18 was a fully specific and sensitive indicator for the remaining brain stem function (no false positives and rare false negatives). In the patients in whom we followed the course of progression from coma to brain death, loss of N18 seemed to parallel loss of spontaneous respiration as expected from the proximity between the N18 generator and the respiratory centre, although more intensive observation of the course of sequential loss of individual variables is necessary to confirm the above hypothesis.
The ABRs were indistinguishable from those in brain death (no more than wave I and small wave II) in four of 13 comatose recordings in the present series, indicating a higher percentage of false negatives for detecting remaining brain stem function. This must be due to the fact that ABRs reflecting pontine and midbrain functions cannot reflect medullary function because in three of four recordings in which ABRs failed to show brain stem activities, N18 was preserved together with spontaneous respiration, cough reflex, or decerebrate response. The last result further supports our hypothesis that N18 is generated at the medulla oblongata.
There was no recording where N18 was preserved when clinical signs indicated brain death. Namely, it never happened that N18 could detect remaining brain stem function in the patient clinically diagnosed as brain dead, at least within the present series. In this sense, the clinical determination of brain death was sufficiently safe and N18 gave no additional information. However, this does not mean that N18 has no value. The situation was the same for ABRs because there was no recording in the present series where ABRs showed preserved brain stem functions (preservation of III or later waves) despite the clinical diagnosis of brain death.
As a principle, the diagnosis of brain death is a rule out diagnosis and each clinical or neurophysiological variable can evaluate the function of only a part of the brain stem or the whole brain. Namely, it is an inherent limitation of not only neurophysiological24 but also clinical indices used for the diagnosis of brain death that no single index is so powerful that it can unequivocally diagnose brain death by itself. Accordingly, we have no reason to exclude an index which can reliably and non-invasively evaluate an aspect of brain stem function. There is actually a report of rare cases in which evoked potentials excluded brain death despite clinical diagnosis of the event.37 An index which gives rare false negatives and no false positives, such as N18, must be especially useful because its preservation definitely excludes brain death and its loss strongly suggests brain death. In any event, it is of value that we have obtained an electrophysiological measure which is considered to be an indicator of medullary function. Further investigation is necessary to establish the usefulness of N18 as a new criterion of brain death.
This study is supported by Grants-in-Aid for Scientific Research (09670669) from the Ministry of Education, Science, Sports and Culture of Japan and by The Nakabayashi Trust for ALS Research.
If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.