OBJECTIVES To evaluate the relation between brain displacement, clinical signs and symptoms, and local cerebral blood flow (lCBF) in patients with chronic subdural haematoma (CSDH).
METHODS Forty five patients (age range 58–87 years, mean 71.9 (SD 8.4)) with unilateral CSDH were studied. Patients were categorised into three groups: I, headache (n=16); II, paresis (n=14); and III, mental change (n=15). T1 weighted MR images were obtained in all patients preoperatively. Quantitative values of maximum haematoma thickness, midline shift, and brain rotation angle were measured on axial and coronal MR images. In 21 patients, lCBF was measured by Xe enhanced CT. Values for lCBF were obtained in selected regions of interest in the frontal cortex, thalamus, and hemisphere on both the haematoma and contralateral sides.
RESULTS The lCBF reduction in the ipsilateral frontal cortex showed the best linear correlation with haematoma thickness (r=0.57), whereas the reduction in the ipsilateral thalamus had the most significant correlation with pineal shift (r=0.65) and third ventricle incline (r=0.67). In patients with paresis, lCBF decreased significantly on the ipsilateral side of both the frontal cortex and thalamus (p<0.05), whereas patients with mental change showed a significant reduction of lCBF on both sides of the thalamus (p<0.01) and in the ipsilateral frontal cortex (p<0.01).
CONCLUSIONS The lCBF reduction and clinical symptoms correlated well with local brain displacement in patients with CSDH. The lCBF in the central cerebral area including the thalamus was reduced in patients with clinical signs. The mental changes found were thought to derive from mild impairment of consciousness due to upper brain stem displacement.
- brain displacement
- cerebral blood flow
- chronic subdural haematoma
Statistics from Altmetric.com
The exact mechanism by which brain function is impaired when compressed and displaced by an intracranial mass is unclear. Several authors have analyzed the relation between the clinical symptoms and the brain shift or transtentorial herniation in patients with supratentorial masses.1-3 However, these reports showed only a relation between brain displacement or transtentorial herniation and consciousness disturbance.
There have been only a few reports regarding local cerebral blood flow (lCBF) and metabolism in patients with chronic supratentorial masses.4-8 Although they showed reduction of CBF and metabolism in patients with clinical manifestations, the contribution of brain displacements to these clinical manifestations was not elucidated in detail.
In our previous study,9 we showed the relations between brain displacement on MRI and electrophysiological changes measured by brain stem auditory evoked response (BAER) in patients with chronic subdural haematoma (CSDH). The results indicated that the latency of central conduction time was prolonged and brain stem kinking occurred when the supratentorial mass became larger. In the present study, we evaluated the relation between brain displacement, clinical signs and symptoms, and lCBF reduction in patients with CSDH. We also discuss the mechanism by which an intracranial mass may cause brain dysfunction.
Materials and methods
We studied 45 patients (age range 58–87 years; mean 71.9 (SD 8.4)) with unilateral CSDH. Informed consent was obtained from all patients or their families. Patients were grouped into three by the symptoms and signs as follows; headache alone without any neurological deficits (group I: headache, n=16), paresis of the limbs without mental changes (group II: paresis, n=14), and mental change with or without paresis (group III: mental change, n=15). In group III, 12 patients were hemiparetic. The average age was 72.9 in group I, 70.9 in group II, and 71.9 in group III. Mental changes in patients of‘ group III included consciousness disturbance (delirium, drowsiness, and fluctuating consciousness, which ranged from 9 to 13 on the Glasgow coma scale) and dementia (impairment of memory and intellect with intact sensorium). A history of trauma in the preceding months was elicited in 76% (34/45) of the patients. None of the patients had bilateral lesions or other cerebral pathology. All but two patients in group I were operated on for the evacuation of the haematoma soon after the examinations.
Both coronal and axial T1 weighted MR images were obtained in all patients preoperatively using a Shimadzu SMT 150, 1.5 tesla MRI system (TR 500 ms, TE 26 ms, 10 mm thickness, 256 by 256 pixels). Maximum haematoma thickness and brain rotation angles (the incline of the third ventricle and the axis of brain stem) were obtained on the coronal images (fig 1 A). The midline shifts of the septum pellucidum and pineal body were measured on the axial images. The values were converted to true dimensions using the linear scale on the film images. Details were described in our previous report.9
In 21 patients, including seven in group I, eight in group II, and six in group III, lCBF was measured preoperatively with Xe enhanced CT. In all the patients having CBF measurements, mean arterial blood pressure (MABP) and arterial blood gas were also examined, and found to be within a physiological range (MABP 80–120 mm Hg; PaCO2, 33–48 mm Hg; pH, 7.35–7.45). An Xe-CT CBF study was carried out with a TCT-900S CT scanner (Toshiba Corp, Tokyo, Japan), and an AZ-723 Xe inhalation system with end tidal Xe monitor (Anzai Sogyo Co, Tokyo, Japan). All patients inhaled a mixture of 30% Xe in oxygen through a face mask for 6 minutes. Brain CT images were obtained every 45 seconds for 6 minutes during the wash in period and for another 6 minutes during the wash out period. A CBF mapping image was created by processing the endotidal build up curve and tissue build up curve using 02C-CBF imaging software (Toshiba Corp). The scan consisted of a single slice in a plane through the pineal body parallel to the orbitomeatal line at the level of the basal ganglia in all but four patients. In each patient, absolute values of lCBF were obtained in selected regions of interest in the frontal cortex, thalamus, and hemisphere on both the haematoma and contralateral sides (fig 1 B). Details were described in our previous papers.10 11 The flow value of the thalamus in four patients was not obtained because the CBF image was scanned in a more superior slice due to the location of the haematoma. Normal lCBF values were obtained in five volunteers (all men; age range 53–65, mean 57.8 years), and mean values were calculated in 10 hemispheres: 37.2 (2.6 ml)/100 g/min in the frontal cortex, 58.2 (SD7.2) ml/100 g/min in the thalamus, and 31.2 (SD 3.9 ml)/100 g/min in the hemisphere.
The mean lCBF value in each region was plotted against the values for maximum haematoma thickness, brain midline shift, and brain rotation angle for all subjects. Correlations between the brain displacement and lCBF were analyzed by linear regression analysis. The parameters of brain displacement were compared between the groups by one factor factorial analysis of variance (ANOVA). Values for lCBF of each group were also compared in each brain area by one factor factorial ANOVA.
RELATION BETWEEN CLINICAL SYMPTOMS AND BRAIN DISPLACEMENT
The relations among the maximum haematoma thickness, septum shift, and clinical symptoms in the three groups are shown in figure 2. In group I (headache), haematoma thickness was less than 20 mm and septum shift was less than 10 mm in all cases. All but three patients in group II (paresis) had a haematoma thickness of more than 20 mm and septum shift of less than 10 mm. All but one patient in group III (mental change) showed a haematoma thickness of more than 20 mm, and all but four patients showed a septum shift of more than 10 mm. The data on maximum haematoma thickness and brain displacements including septum shift, pineal shift, third ventricle rotation, and brain stem rotation in the three groups are summarised in table 1. The haematoma thickness in groups II and III was significantly greater than in group I (p<0.01), but there was no significant difference between group II and group III. Both shifts of septum and pineal body in group II were greater than those in group I (p<0.01), and both shifts in group III were larger than those in group II (p<0.01). Neuroaxis rotations of the third ventricle and brain stem in the coronal plane were significantly greater in group III than in either group I or group II (p<0.01).
RELATION BETWEEN BRAIN DISPLACEMENT AND LCBF
The lCBF value of each patient for each region was plotted against haematoma thickness and brain displacements. The lCBF decreased linearly in all areas corresponding to the severity of brain displacements. The reduction of lCBF in the frontal cortex on the haematoma side had the best linear correlation with haematoma thickness (fig 3 A; y=39.0–0.4x, r=0.57), whereas the reduction of lCBF in the thalamus on the haematoma side had the most significant correlation with the pineal shift (fig 3 B; y=56.2–2.8x,r=0.65) and the third ventricle incline (r=0.67, not shown). The magnitude of the lCBF reduction, indicated as the incline of the line obtained by the linear regression analysis in fig 3, was greater in the thalamus than in the frontal cortex due to the brain displacement.
RELATION BETWEEN CLINICAL SYMPTOMS AND LCBF
Figures 3 A and B show the relation between lCBF and the clinical symptoms in each patient. The patients with mental change had the greatest reduction of lCBF, those with paresis had a moderate reduction of lCBF, and those with headache alone had the least reduction of lCBF in both the frontal cortex and thalamus on the haematoma side. These data are summarised in table 2 and figure 4. In group I (headache), lCBF did not change significantly compared with the normal values in any region even though the normal values were obtained from non-age matched volunteers. In group II (paresis), lCBFs in all regions decreased significantly compared with the normal values in each region. However, only lCBFs in the frontal cortex and thalamus on the haematoma side were significantly different from those in group I (p<0.05, each). In group III (mental change), lCBFs in all regions also showed a significant reduction compared with the normal values. In comparison, the lCBFs in group III in both the frontal cortex and thalamus on the haematoma side significantly decreased compared with group I (p<0.01). Furthermore, lCBF in the thalamus on the contralateral side in group III significantly decreased compared with that in group II (p<0.05).
BRAIN DISPLACEMENT AND CLINICAL SYMPTOMS
Altered mental function and hemiparesis are among the most common features of CSDH in older patients.12 Mental changes have been categorised into three types13: consciousness disturbance, dementia, and mixed type. In this study, we included all patients with mental changes in one category (group III) because of the difficulty in differentiating between consciousness disturbance and dementia due to the wide variation in intellectual change and fluctuation of consciousness level.
Chronic subdural haematoma has a relatively uniform location, and the brain displacement is primarily affected by the size of the haematoma. In our previous study,9 we demonstrated the relations among the brain displacements of the various parts of the midline structure associated with CSDH. The data indicated that the midline structures of the brain shifted and rotated when the haematoma thickness increased beyond the level of spatial compensation, and that midbrain kinking occurred in an advanced stage. In the present study, we evaluated the relation between the brain displacement and clinical symptoms. The data showed that the clinical symptoms were related to both the haematoma thickness and brain displacements. In the patients without neurological deficits (group I), the septum shift was limited to about 4 mm, although the haematoma compressed the superficial structure of the cortex to a greater degree (measured as maximum haematoma thickness; mean thickness 14 mm). In such cases, the mass effect on the midline structures might be reduced by cerebral atrophy. When the haematoma thickness increased beyond about 20 mm, both the superficial and deep brain structures were deformed, and the neurological signs of hemiparesis and mental changes occurred in relation to the degree of midline displacement.
Several authors have reported relations between disturbance of consciousness and brain displacement with unilateral masses using neuroimaging techniques. Ropper1 reported that in patients with acute masses, horizontal displacement of the brain above the tentorium measured by CT is more closely related to impairment of the conscious level than to the brain stem compression due to the tentorial herniation. From further analysis using MRI, Ropper2stressed that most patients with acute unilateral masses have upper brain stem displacement predominantly due to horizontal shift at or above the tentorium. Reich et al 3 demonstrated the relation between clinical signs and brain herniation with supratentorial masses by measurements of midsagittal MRI in both acute and chronic masses. Their results showed that in acute illnesses MRI changes anticipated or confirmed clinical signs of brain herniation, whereas in chronic cases clinical and MRI findings were less correlated. Our data also showed a wide range of brain displacement in each group. Although all the previous reports focused mainly on the relation between brain displacement and disturbance of consciousness, our data indicated graded changes of clinical symptoms, including non-neurological signs, hemiparesis, or mental change, related to brain displacement with a supratentorial mass.
BRAIN DISPLACEMENT AND lCBF
The present study demonstrated that lCBF in all areas decreased linearly with an increase in haematoma thickness or the severity of brain displacement. Although the lCBF in the ipsilateral frontal cortex was most affected by haematoma thickness, in the ipsilateral thalamus it correlated best with the displacement of the deep brain structures, including the pineal shift and neuroaxis rotation. The cause of hemiparesis was reported to be the reduced lCBF in the rolandic cortex5 or in deep structures including the thalamus.6 Our data for hemiparetic patients (group II) showed that the lCBF was reduced in both the ipsilateral frontal cortex and thalamus. The displacement of the superficial structures, measured as haematoma thickness, was related to the displacement of the deep brain structures when the haematoma thickness increased beyond spatial compensation, so hemiparesis may be induced by the reduction of lCBF in the ipsilateral pyramidal tract, including both the frontal cortex and subcortical structures.
Tanaka et al 14 reported that the cause of clinical signs including hemiparesis and mental change was the lCBF reduction in the deep structures, especially in the thalamus. Because patients with hemiparesis and mental change were analyzed together, distinct differences in the mechanism of hemiparesis and mental change could not be determined. Our data clearly demonstrate that the lCBF reduction in the ipsilateral thalamus alone did not relate to mental changes; changes in cognition were associated with the reduction on both sides of the thalamus. This bilateral lCBF reduction in the thalamus was thought to be closely related to displacement and dysfunction in the upper brain stem (midbrain). Our previous data on the relation between the brain stem displacement and the prolongation of central conduction time on BAER also support the importance of midbrain kinking at the advanced stage of brain displacement.9 These results suggest that the mental changes in patients with CSDH were mainly disturbance in consciousness due to the dysfunction of the deep brain structures. Although it seems possible that higher cognitive function was impaired by the decreased lCBF in the ipsilateral frontal cortex, this may be ruled out in the present cases because the reduction of lCBF in the ipsilateral frontal cortex also existed in the paretic patients without mental changes (group II).
Normal lCBF values in our institute were not age matched for this study. Because CBF is thought to be reduced in elderly subjects,15 the age matched normal values might be lower than the values used. Thus, there may be no significant differences in the data of lCBF in clinical groups compared with normal values. However, comparisons among the clinical groups I to III showed significant differences in lCBF (see results section).
MECHANISM OF CLINICAL SYMPTOMS
It is still unclear how intracranial masses impair brain function—that is, reduced metabolic demand, reduced CBF, or raised intracranial pressure (ICP). Little is known about the metabolic status of the brain with CSDH. Ishikawa et al 8 reported that in CSDH, the lCBF and cerebral metabolic rate for oxygen (CMRO2) in the affected hemisphere were reduced but the oxygen extraction fraction (OEF) was raised with normal cerebral blood volume, and that these changes were pronounced mainly in the anterior central cerebral area. Although they thought that the hypoperfusion and hypometabolism in their patients were insufficient to cause neuronal energy failure, CMRO2as the index of metabolic status significantly decreased. Our previous finding of brain pH in patients with CSDH also showed a decrease in pH (acidosis), possibly due to the hypoperfusion.7Brodersen et al 4 suggested that CBF reduction in patients with CSDH was probably secondary to a reduced metabolic demand. Although there are still no definite conclusions in this regard, our data indicated that lCBF reduction and clinical symptoms were well correlated with brain displacement. Further studies are needed to determine the primary cause of clinical presentation due to the brain displacement—that is, reduced metabolic demand or reduced CBF. Increased ICP with mass lesions may cause the generalised reduction of CBF. Although ICP was not measured in our study, it is reportedly often near normal in older patients with CSDH.16
The present study demonstrated that lCBF does not always decrease in the area adjacent to a haematoma, but often does decrease in the central cerebral area including the thalamus. Reduction in CBF and clinical symptoms were well correlated with brain displacement. Mental changes found were thought to derive from mild impairment of consciousness due to upper brain stem displacement.
We thank Dr M Furuse, Dr H Kuchiwaki, Dr T Hirano, Dr K Yoshida, Mrs H Koida, and Mr A Izawa of Nakatsugawa Municipal General Hospital for their technical assistance and management of the patients.
If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.