Objectives: Hemichorea sometimes occurs after lesions that selectively involve the caudate nucleus, putamen, and globus pallidus. Some reports have hypothesised that the loss of subthalamic nucleus control on the internal segment of the globus pallidus, followed by the disinhibition of the thalamus may contribute to chorea. However, the pathophysiology is poorly understood. Therefore, clinicoradiological localisation was evaluated and a comparison of the haemodynamic status of the basal ganglia and thalamus was made.
Methods: Six patients presenting with acute onset of hemichorea were assessed. Neuroimaging studies, including MRI and SPECT examinations in addition to detailed biochemical tests, were performed. A semiquantitative analysis was performed by comparing the ratio of blood flow between patients and normal controls. In addition, the ratio of perfusion asymmetry was calculated as the ratio between each area contralateral to the chorea and that homolateral to the chorea. The comparison was made with a two sample t test.
Results: The causes of hemichorea found consisted of four cases of acute stroke, one non-ketotic hyperglycaemia, and one systemic lupus erythematosus. Brain MRI indicated lesion sites in the contralateral putamen, globus pallidus, caudate nucleus, and subthalamic nucleus. A significant decrease in the ratio of blood flow in the basal ganglia contralateral to the chorea and a significant increase in the thalamus was found when comparing the perfusion asymmetries, which were calculated as the ratio of cerebral blood flow (CBF) for each region to that in the homolateral occipital area (p<0.05).
Conclusion: An alteration in CBF in both the contralateral thalamus and basal ganglia reflect the loss of pallidal inhibitory input from the pallidum to the thalamus. This change in CBF may be one of epiphenomena, which implicates an occurrence of hemichorea in humans.
- basal ganglia
- cerebral blood flow
- CBF, cerebral blood flow
- GABA, γ-aminobutyric acid
- GPe, external globus pallidus
- GPi, internal globus pallidus
Statistics from Altmetric.com
- CBF, cerebral blood flow
- GABA, γ-aminobutyric acid
- GPe, external globus pallidus
- GPi, internal globus pallidus
Hemichorea occurs suddenly, and is often accompanied by proximal ballistic movement, which may be due to a wide variety of degenerative, vascular, metabolic, or toxic disorders selectively involving the contralateral caudate nucleus, putamen, and globus pallidus.1,2 Additionally, various structural lesions in the contralateral subthalamic nucleus (STN) and the pallidosubthalamic pathway seem to play a critical part in the development of chorea3–5 with an acute vascular accident being the most common pathological process.5
A widely accepted hypothesis used to explain these hyperkinetic disorders suggests that the loss of STN control on the internal segment of the globus pallidus (GPi) is followed by the disinhibition of the thalamus.6 These explanations are in line with experimental data, including the fact that STN lesions result in dyskinesia,7 and that such lesions are associated with reduced levels of spontaneous discharge in the GPi.8 However, there are observations that are difficult to reconcile with simple models of basal ganglia function based primarily on the concept of thalamic disinhibition.9,10
Such models are also able to account for hypokinetic disorders on the basis of excessive basal ganglia outflow. In primates with parkinsonian akinesia induced experimentally, the discharge rate of neurons in the GPi as well as in the STN has been found to be abnormally high.11,12 This is consistent with thalamic disinhibition models showing that akinesia in humans with idiopathic Parkinson's disease can be relieved by selective stereotactic GPi lesions.13
The distribution of 99mTc-hexamethylpropylene aminoxime (HMPAO) within the brain is proportional to cerebral blood flow (CBF).14 When cerebral autoregulation is preserved, the CBF is directly related to metabolic needs, which in turn depends on neuronal functional activity.15 However, since the static HMPAO single photon emission computed tomography (SPECT) did not allow the absolute quantification of the regional CBF, there are some limitations in comparing directly the relative perfusion ratios in the region of interest between normal and pathological conditions. Therefore, we speculated this movement disorder to have an asymmetric pathology on the contralateral hemisphere because hemichorea interchangeably involves one side of the body. Semiquantitative analysis was performed by calculating the ratio of perfusion asymmetry between each area contralateral and homolateral to the chorea.
SUBJECTS AND METHODS
Six patients (four men, two women) with an age range from 27 to 73 presented with hemichorea. Routine laboratory tests included the measurement of serum glucose, electrolytes, and urinary ketone concentrations. A brain MRI using a 1.5 Tesla superconducting system (Magnetom, Siemens) was obtained 3 days after onset of abnormal movement. The aetiologies of chorea in each patient were classified by laboratory and neuroimaging data. Another six age matched subjects without any other neurological diseases served as normal controls.
A brain SPECT was performed after intravenous injection of 740 MBq 99mTc HMPAO with lorazepam to reduce movement artifacts. However, the chorea was not completely abolished on examination. The data were obtained with a two head rotating gamma camera (MS II, Siemens, Germany) with a fanbeam collimator. A full 360° rotation was acquired with a matrix of 128×128. 10 mm thick axial slices, tilted along the orbitofrontal line, were reconstructed by a Butterworth filtered backprojection.
Analysis was performed both visually and quantitatively. Two experienced nuclear medicine physicians who were unaware of the patient's clinical state, reviewed all the SPECT results.
99mTc-HMPAO uptake in the basal ganglia, thalamus, cerebellum, frontal, parietal, temporal and occipital area was quantified by placing appropriate regions of interest (ROI) on positions standardised under MRI guidance (fig 1). Two observers, blind to the clinical state, performed all quantitative analyses.
The analyses were performed by comparing the uptake in the region under evaluation with the uptake in a region unaffected by the disease. The occipital area was pathologically spared in the chorea and used as the referenced region.16 The CBF for each region was expressed as the ratio of HMPAO uptake in that region to that in the homolateral occipital area and the CBF ratios were compared between the patients with hemichorea and the normal controls. Additionally, the ratio of perfusion asymmetry was calculated as the ratio between each area contralateral and homolateral to the chorea. A comparison was made with a two sample t test.
Clinical and neuroimaging data
Table 1 summarises the clinical, biochemical, and brain MRI results. The causes of the hemichorea found consisted of four patients with acute stroke (patients 2–5), one with non-ketotic hyperglycaemia (patient 6), and one with systemic lupus erythematosus (patient 1). Five patients (2–6) had a hemichorea involving the contralateral putamen, caudate nucleus, globus pallidus, and subthalamic nucleus. Patient 1, with systemic lupus erythematosus, had a hemichorea in the left limbs, but showed no definite anatomical lesion on brain MRI (fig 2 A and B). All patients received haloperidol (2–10 mg) and patient 1 was prescribed 60 mg oral prednisolone. The chorea subsided within 1–2 weeks after treatment.
The brain SPECT showed a decreased blood perfusion of the basal ganglia and an increased perfusion of the thalamus contralateral to the side of the choreic movement in all patients (fig 2 C). Patients 1, 3, 5, and 6 also had mildly decreased perfusion over the homolateral cerebellar hemisphere and patient 2 had increased perfusion over the right temporal region and patient 5 had decreased perfusion over the left parietal region. In the occipital area, no perfusion asymmetry was found. In addition, there was no perfusion defect in the controls.
Table 2 summarises the blood flow ratios in the basal ganglia and thalamus referenced to that in the homolateral occipital areas. The means (SD) of the ratio in the basal ganglia and thalamus contralateral to the choreic movement were 0.88 (0.05) and 0.95 (0.06), respectively, and those for the region homolateral to the chorea were 0.97 (0.06) and 0.90 (0.06), respectively. By contrast with the patient group, the means (SD) of the right and left basal ganglia and thalamus blood flow in the controls were 0.98 (0.08), 0.96 (0.07) and 0.99 (0.03), 1.01 (0.03), respectively. When comparing the percentage of perfusion asymmetry with the normal controls, a significant decrease was found in the ratio of the flow of the basal ganglia contralateral to the chorea (p=0.014) and a significant increase was seen in the thalamus (p=0.001). However, there was no significant difference in the ratio of blood flow over the basal ganglia (p=0.074) and thalamus (p=0.218) contralateral to the chorea compared with that in the control group. Furthermore, no other CBF abnormalities were detected in the frontal, parietal, temporal, and cerebellar areas (p>0.05).
Experimental hemichorea models can be produced by injecting a γ-aminobutyric acid (GABA) antagonist into the external segment of the globus pallidus (GPe) or STN.17,18 The interruption of GABAnergic transmission from the striatum to the GPe would lead to abnormally increased GPe neuron activity, which exerts inhibitory action on the STN.19 Increased STN inhibition would result in the loss of its control on the GPi. Besides excitatory STN inputs,20 the GPi neurons also receive inhibitory afferent inputs directly from the striatum. The imbalance between the indirect excitatory and direct inhibitory pathways ultimately leads to a disinhibition of the motor thalamus.
However, this simple pathophysiological model of the chorea has rarely been reported in humans. There are only two reports showing an increase in thalamic perfusion after a striatal ischaemic lesion21 or an increase in thalamic glucose metabolism in Huntington's disease.22 Moreover, there are observations that are difficult to reconcile with these simple models of basal ganglia function based primarily on the concept of thalamic disinhibition. One of the most noteworthy discrepancies involves the fact that lesions of the basal ganglia output nuclei do not result in dyskinesia.9 Another related problem in thalamic disinhibition theories is that lesions of the ventrolateral thalamus do not result in akinesia. Yet, according to such theories parkinsonian akinesia is generally attributed to increased basal ganglia outflow, which results in excessive inhibition at the ventrolateral thalamus level.6 One possible explanation for this apparent discrepancy is that the functional relevance of the descending basal ganglia outflow to the pedunculopontine nucleus may have been underestimated. In this case, lesions of the thalamus that only block the re-entrant influence of the basal ganglia, may leave intact those descending influences that are conveyed directly to the segmental motor apparatus.
Both SPECT and HMPAO were employed to obtain a functional status of the patients with hemichorea. Although a comparison of the ratio of blood flow over the basal ganglia and thalamus contralateral to the chorea with that in the control group was non-significant, our finding of perfusion asymmetry in the thalamus and the basal ganglia contralateral to the hemichorea was of particular interest because it may reflect the loss of pallidal inhibitory input to the thalamus. The CBF increase seen in the thalamus contralateral to the choreic movement probably reflects increased thalamic neuronal activity, free from inhibitory pallidal control. In addition, as seen in patient 1, a brain SPECT has many advantages over a brain MRI in detecting functional abnormalities in chorea.
Because basal ganglia influence movement primarily through their projections to the primary or secondary areas of the motor cortex, some differences in cortical perfusion were examined in patients with hemichorea. However, in the cortical areas, our patients did not show any differences in the ratio of perfusion contralateral or homolateral to the hemichorea. There have been several studies of the cortical physiological mechanism concerning hyperkinetic disorders. However, the function of the thalamocortical projections and cortical areas, leading to chorea, remains unclear and some controversy still exists.23–26 Although our findings did not disclose the metabolic rate but the relative perfusion rate in the cortical area, this suggests that the chorea is produced by activation of an intact motor cortex by an abnormal or immature trigger pulse in the basal ganglia, which is in agreement with the original proposal by Kanazawa.27 Studying cortical metabolism in patients with hemichorea using positron emission tomography may be necessary.
We postulate that the primary event is a vascular insult in the striatum, leading to a dysfunction of the GABAnergic projection neurons. Consequently, damage to the striatum causes a contralateral hemichorea when the striatal neurons that project through the GPe to the STN are selectively affected. In summary, our interpretation of the hyperperfusion of the thalamus found is in accordance with one of an epiphenomenon, which implicates the occurrence of hemichorea in humans.
This work was supported by grants from the Catholic Medical Center Research Foundation.