Article Text

PDF

NHS Direct for headache
  1. A J Larner
  1. Walton Centre for Neurology and Neurosurgery, Lower Lane, Liverpool L9 7LJ, UK
  1. Correspondence to:
 Dr A J Larner
 a.larnerthewaltoncentre.nhs.uk

Statistics from Altmetric.com

NHS Direct is a government sponsored, nurse led, telephone helpline available throughout the United Kingdom, offering confidential medical advice without recourse to a doctor by using computerised assessment systems based on clinical algorithms.1 As algorithms for the management of headache have been formulated, this might be construed as a condition for which NHS Direct would be well suited to offer an appropriate service. Following a protocol used in previous studies of the use of NHS Direct by patients attending neurology outpatient clinics,2–4 patients with headache were specifically asked about their use of this service.

Of 1000 consecutive unselected patients seen in 118 general neurology outpatient clinics over a period of approximately 10 months by one consultant neurologist, headache was the principal reason for referral or patient complaint during consultation in 208 (21%), a frequency similar to that previously reported by others.5 The neurologist’s diagnoses, using standard diagnostic criteria,6 were: chronic daily headache of tension type (157), drug overuse headache (12), episodic tension type headache (3), and migraine (34); one patient had a cerebral neoplasm, with typical postural features and visual obscurations, and one had coital cephalalgia. Of these 208 patients, 120 (58%) had heard of the NHS Direct telephone helpline. Of these 120 patients, 36 (30%; or 17% of all headache patients) had used the service; only three patients volunteered this information spontaneously. Of the 36 users, in 14 the call to NHS Direct related to headache (39% of NHS Direct users, or 6.7% of all headache patients); two volunteered this information spontaneously. The percentages for awareness and use of NHS Direct in this cohort are similar to those previously reported for an unselected general neurology outpatient clinic surveyed in 2002.3

Of those calling NHS Direct for advice about their headache, five of the 14 reported that they were told to go to hospital or call an ambulance immediately. The neurologist’s diagnoses in these five patients were chronic daily headache of tension type in three, episodic tension type headache in one, and migraine without aura in one (in whom the reported NHS Direct diagnosis was cerebral haemorrhage). One patient was told to go to a local NHS walk-in centre (final diagnosis: chronic tension type headache), and another two patients were told to attend their general practitioner (both with chronic tension type headache). NHS Direct diagnosed transient ischaemic attack in a man thought by the neurologist to have migraine without headache (migraine equivalent). One patient with chronic tension type headache was told to lie in a dark room. One patient phoned for information about side effects of analgesic medication. Three could not recall the outcome of their call to NHS Direct.

Proposals for changes in the primary care of headache in the UK, issued by the British Association for the Study of Headache (BASH), described the role of NHS Direct in headache management as “uncertain,” as “algorithms in use cannot provide for the taking of an adequate history to inform advice given.”7 The current study, although hospital based and reliant on patient report, with all their inherent biases, has provided no evidence to contradict that view. The suggestions emanating from NHS Direct were neither dangerous nor useful. Hence the study does not suggest that NHS Direct can currently replace clinical assessment by a practitioner trained in the diagnosis and management of headache disorders.

References

View Abstract

Request permissions

If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.