Article Text

PDF

Letter from Cuba
  1. A J Wills
  1. Department of Neurology, Queen’s Medical Centre, Nottingham, UK
  1. Correspondence to:
 Dr Adrian J Wills, Department of Neurology, Queen’s Medical Centre, Nottingham, UK; email:
 adewills61{at}hotmail.com

Statistics from Altmetric.com

Imagine a country where housing, health, and education are free, without drug reps or private medicine, where the average consultant neurologist earns US $30 per month and a mobile phone is rarer than hens’ teeth. This is not Arcadia, but a real place, where I was privileged to spend a week as a guest of the Department of Neurology, Santiago. This is Cuba.

Cuba is an anachronism in these days of the “new world order” and clings tenaciously to the tenets of socialism, emphasising social justice at the expense of economic freedom. As a consequence, although in close geographical proximity to the USA, political relations between the two nations have been anything other than neighbourly. Although the “Bay of Pigs” invasion and the Cuban missile crisis seem long ago, the US continues to impose a punitive economic blockade. Cuban nationals working in the US have severe restrictions on their freedom of movement. Any ship, of whatever nationality, that docks in a Cuban port is quarantined from US waters for a period of 6 months. US citizens can be heavily fined and theoretically imprisoned on their return merely for visiting Cuba. The Cuban Democracy Act prohibits foreign subsidiaries of US companies from trading with Cuba.

The collapse of the Soviet Union and removal of various trade subsidies, particularly linking sugar for oil, was a disaster for Cuba and economic conditions deteriorated markedly in the 1990s. At the beginning of this period doctors’ salaries were averaging at US$ 600 per month (20 times higher than the current figure). The whole population saw a marked decline in living standards with an increasing reliance on the state subsidised ration consisting of bread, rice, and other basic necessities. Whether the poor nutritional sate of the population contributed to the well-publicised epidemic of optic and peripheral neuropathies has been hotly debated. Between 1991 and 1993 over 50 000 Cubans were affected by optic neuropathy, peripheral neuropathy, myelopathy, and deafness in various combinations.1 The risk was higher in smokers and reduced in subjects with higher dietary intakes of methionine, vitamin B12, riboflavin, and niacin.2 In 1993 all Cuban citizens were provided with vitamin supplements and only 0.1% of the affected population were left with permanent sequelae.3

Economic conditions are now improving slowly, with tourism providing much needed hard currency. This has caused problems, including a resurgence of prostitution, although street crime and drug trafficking seem to be rare occurrences.

GENERAL HEALTHCARE

Before the revolution Cuba had 3.9 hospital beds per 1000 population. This figure is now 7.3 per 1000 with 1 doctor per 174 inhabitants (1 General Practitioner per 600 v UK figure of 1/1800).4 Infant mortality is low (6.2/1000 births), comparing favourably with figures from the developed world (USA 7.0/1000, UK 5.7/1000).5 Life expectancy also compares favourably with the industrialised nations. Cuba continues to export doctors to developing nations, particularly in Africa, and these jobs are popular as salaries are often 10 to 20 times greater than those earned domestically.6 Infectious diseases are unusual, HIV still relatively rare, and malaria eradicated. Cardiovascular diseases, diabetes, and cancer are major determinants of morbidity and mortality.

NEUROLOGICAL SERVICES

Each province has a teaching hospital, which provides neurological services for the local population. Students spend 6 years at medical school and general medical training follows this. A neurological residency (specialist registrar equivalent) lasts 3 years, culminating in an exit exam prior to the attainment of consultant status. In contrast to the UK there is no opportunity for a dedicated research period leading to a higher degree. In the Santiago de Cuba province there are 16 consultant neurologists for a population of 1 million (1/60000). The ratio of consultants to residents (specialist registrar equivalent) is 1.6:1. There is no waiting list for neurology outpatient appointments and inpatient beds seem to be easily accessible.

Within each hospital there are dedicated neurology beds as well as a stroke unit. Doctors do not carry bleeps or pagers but are contacted by telephone. Consultants are on-call from home. Modern diagnostic facilities are available, including MRI, CT, EEG/EMG, and angiography. The Helms-Burton law, which by threatening non-US intermediaries with lawsuits in US courts, discourages healthcare investors from trade with Cuba. Maintenance is therefore difficult and when equipment breaks down repairs may take many weeks. As a consequence of the Helms-Burton law Cuban neurologists have a restricted choice of treatments for conditions such as epilepsy and migraine, relying on off-patent drugs, which can be manufactured domestically.

However, most neurological conditions seem to be managed similarly in Cuba as in the UK. There are noticeable differences in a few areas. All patients with severe myasthenia are offered thymectomy, regardless of age. Acetylcholine receptor antibody status cannot be determined so the diagnosis is made clinically and neurophysiologically. Guillain-Barré syndrome is treated with domestically manufactured intravenous immunoglobulin because of the non-availability of plasma exchange.

However, it is in the field of stroke medicine that Cuban achievements seem especially impressive. Following the recommendations of a multidisciplinary commission, there is close integration of hospital and primary care and each polyclinic, (consisting of 10–15 GP practices) is staffed by community based specialists. This has encouraged an intensive educational campaign aimed at healthcare workers and patients; warning of the dangers of hypertension and transient ischaemic attacks, resulting in a dramatic (30%) reduction in stroke mortality and morbidity over 5 years. All patients with stroke are admitted to a stroke unit with dedicated beds (including high dependency beds) staffed by a multidisciplinary team. CT and carotid ultrasound are routine, whereas thrombolysis is not available.

CONCLUDING REMARKS

A common philosophy, based on the principle of health for all, which is free at the point of demand, underpins the NHS and Cuban healthcare system. This common vision could form the basis for closer collaboration in future. We in the UK could benefit from this liaison, particularly while attempting to provide high quality neurological care with economic efficiency. UK neurology needs to change so that patients with acute neurological problems can be promptly seen by someone with neurological expertise. UK neurologists should be more closely involved in the management of common neurological problems such as stroke and head injury. The Cuban model of healthcare could provide a useful paradigm for change. The benefits for Cuba are self-evident, especially if our political masters have the courage to subvert the US trade embargo, and challenge Cuba’s ill-deserved portrayal as a pariah nation.

Acknowledgments

I would like to thank Dr FR Miyares for assistance in the preparation of this article.

REFERENCES

View Abstract

Request permissions

If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.