Article Text

This article has a correction. Please see:

PDF

Sjögren’s syndrome associated painful sensory neuropathy without sensory ataxia
  1. K Mori,
  2. M Iijima,
  3. M Sugiura,
  4. H Koike,
  5. N Hattori,
  6. H Ito,
  7. M Hirayama,
  8. G Sobue
  1. Department of Neurology, Nagoya University Graduate School of Medicine, Nagoya, Japan
  1. Correspondence to:
 Dr G Sobue, Department of Neurology, Nagoya University Graduate School of Medicine, Nagoya 466–8550 Japan; 
 sobueg{at}med.nagoya-u.ac.jp

Statistics from Altmetric.com

Sensory neuropathy with prominent ataxia reflecting kinesthetic sensory impairment is a well recognised form of neuropathy associated with Sjögren’s syndrome.1–4 Pathologically, T cell invasion of dorsal root ganglia, loss of large sensory neurons, and secondary large fibre degeneration is seen in this neuropathy.4 However, a form of neuropathy associated with Sjögren’s syndrome, presenting with pain and superficial sensory involvement without sensory ataxia has been described anecdotally5 and in a case report.6 Clinicopathological details of the second form of neuropathy have not been elucidated. In this report we describe seven patients with Sjögren’s syndrome showing painful sensory neuropathy without sensory ataxia.

Patients studied were referred for painful neuropathy to Nagoya University Hospital and its affiliated institutions. All seven patients fulfilled diagnostic criteria for Sjögren’s syndrome by the American-European Consensus Group7 and showed painful peripheral neuropathy (table 1). Patients included six women and one man, ranging from 25 to 72 years old. In all patients initial symptom of neuropathy was paraesthesia or painful dysaesthesia in the most distal portions of the extremities, later extending proximally to involve the entire legs and arms. The trunk became involved in three patients, and the trigeminal nerve was impaired in three patients. Asymmetry in sensory impairment was present in four patients. None of the patients showed sensory ataxia in the initial phase. Most patients retained essentially normal muscle strength, but patient 1 showed slight weakness in distal limb muscles. Painful sensation was the most characteristic, and this symptom compromised activities of daily living in all patients. Superficial sensation for pinprick and temperature was prominently impaired. Deep sensation such as joint position and vibratory sense was substantially well preserved. Sensory ataxia and Romberg’s sign was not seen. Autonomic dysfunction was seen in four patients including Adie’s pupils, urinary disturbance, and loss of 123I-MIBG cardiac accumulation; however, orthostatic hypotension was not present. Apparent hypohidrosis was seen in three patients. Thermal stimulation in two patients, resulted in absent sweating on the forehead, trunk, arms, and legs, with preserved sweat gland function on pirocarpine test. Thermography showed abnormal skin temperature gradient in four patients. Deep tendon reflexes were comparatively well preserved except in two patients. Motor nerve conduction studies showed no slowing (mean (SD) 52.3 (3.9) m/s in the median, 44.8 (6.1) m/s in the tibial nerves) and preserved compound muscle action potentials (CMAPs) (7.5 (3.5) mV in the median, 9.0 (6.3) mV in the tibial nerves). Sensory nerve conduction (50.1 (6.0) m/s in the median, 47.2 (10.4) m/s in the sural nerves) and sensory nerve action potentials (SNAPs) (13.6 (11.7) uV in the median and 9.0 (6.3) uV in the sural nerves) were generally well preserved; only in patient 4, SNAPs were not evoked. Somatosensory evoked potentials (SEPs) were also well preserved (mean (SD) 20.0 (1.1) ms at N20, 13.7 (1.2) ms at N13, and 9.3 (0.4) ms at N9).

Table 1

Clinical symptoms and histopathological findings

Sural nerve biopsy in five patients showed a variable degree of myelinated fibre loss, predominantly affecting small diameter fibres (table 1, fig 1). Unmyelinated fibre density also was severely reduced. Axonal sprouting was essentially absent in all patients. In teased fibre preparations, degeneration was seen in 32% to 55% of axons, predominantly small diameter fibres. Vasculitis was not seen.

Figure 1

(A) Transverse section of a sural nerve specimen from a control subject. (B) Specimen from a patient of painful sensory neuropathy with predominant small fibre loss associated with Sjögren’s syndrome (patient 1). Small diameter myelinated fibres are more noticeably involved and no axonal sprouting. Bars=25 μm.

Patient 2 developed sensory ataxia in the legs over the next nine years, and more details of this patient are given below. Patient 4 developed localised sensory ataxia in the fingers of the right hand over 11 years. Other patients showed persistent painful sensory neuropathy with gradual extension of distribution over 4 to 11 years of follow up.

CASE REPORT

A 68 year old man had painful dysaesthesia and numbness in the feet for about 10 years, with spread to the proximal of the legs and arms. When he was 56 years old, he noticed painful dysaesthesia in the legs, and subsequently in the hands. Neurological examination demonstrated light touch and pinprick were disturbed, and painful dysaesthesia was elicited in glove and stocking distribution. Vibration and joint position sense was comparatively well preserved for the first time. Sensory ataxia and Romberg’s sign were not seen. Deep tendon reflexes were well preserved in upper limbs, but mildly decreased in lower limbs. Muscle strength was normal. Autonomic disturbance was not present. Nerve conductions were nearly normal except for sensory conduction in the median nerve, 40 m/s. SNAPs were well preserved. Result of routine blood haematology and biochemistry screening tests were normal. CSF protein was 33 mg/dl with no cells. A sural nerve biopsy specimen revealed myelinated fibre loss predominantly involving small diameter fibres with axonal degeneration.

In the next nine years, involvement of deep sensation gradually developed. At 68 years old, he showed sensory ataxia in the legs and positive Romberg’s sign without muscle weakness. The deep tendon reflexes were almost absent. Motor nerve conduction velocities were still preserved, but sensory nerve action potentials were not elicited in the median and sural nerves. At this time, sicca symptoms were obvious, and a Rose Bengal test was positive. A lip biopsy specimen showed periacinar lymphocytic infiltration. Second sural nerve biopsy on the other side showed severe large fibre loss as well as small fibre loss without axonal sprouts.

DISCUSSION

The most well recognised form of Sjögren’s syndrome associated neuropathy has been sensory ataxic neuropathy associated with profound impairment of kinesthetic sensation.1–4,8–10 Neuropathologically, T cell invasion in the dorsal root ganglion as well as loss of large ganglion neurons and their large axons have been verified.4 However clinicopathological findings in our patients differed remarkably from those of sensory ataxic neuropathy. Painful sensation and hyperalgia in our patients suggested involvement of small nociceptive nerve fibres as has been demonstrated.11

Indeed, in sural nerve of our patients, small myelinated and unmyelinated fibres were predominantly involved; electrophysiologically, amplitudes of SNAPs were comparatively preserved, particularly in contrast with sensory ataxic neuropathy. Findings in the dorsal root ganglion in this neuropathy have not been described, but predominant small fibre loss, extremely rare axonal sprouts, lack of vasculitis, lack of motor involvement, and fairly well preserved SEPs suggest that small dorsal root ganglion neurons can be involved.

As demonstrated by the clinical course of our patients, some patients show persistent symptoms or a slowly progressive course while remaining limited to a painful small fibre type of neuropathy, while others, including one of our patients, may later develop sensory ataxic neuropathy presumably involving large sensory neurons. Additionally, one of our patients developed localised unilateral sensory ataxia in the fingers, suggesting that some patients may develop localised sensory ataxia. These observations suggest that painful sensory neuropathy with predominant small fibre loss and sensory ataxic large fibre neuropathy are elements of a spectrum of sensory neuropathy in Sjögren’s syndrome.

In summary, these patients suggest that painful sensory neuropathy with predominant small fibre loss is an identifiable subtype of Sjögren’s syndrome associated neuropathy.

REFERENCES

View Abstract

  • .

    Abstract
    We encountered seven patients with Sj�gren�s syndrome associated painful sensory neuropathy without sensory ataxia. Predominant small fibre loss without axonal sprouting was seen in the sural nerve specimens. Preserved somatosensory evoked potentials and nerve conduction also suggested predominant small axonal sensory neuropathy.

    Footnotes

    • Competing interests: none declared.

    Request permissions

    If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.

    Linked Articles

    • Correction
      BMJ Publishing Group Ltd