Background: Long term effects of subthalamic nucleus (STN) stimulation on cognition, mood, and behaviour are unknown.
Objective: This study evaluated the cognitive, mood, and behavioural effects of bilateral subthalamic nucleus deep brain stimulation (STN DBS) in patients with Parkinson’s disease (PD) followed up for three years.
Methods: A consecutive series of 77 PD patients was assessed before, one, and three years after surgery. Mean (SD) age at surgery was 55 (8). Seven patients died or were lost for follow up. Neuropsychological assessment included a global cognitive scale, memory, and frontal tests. Depression was evaluated using the Beck depression inventory. Assessment of thought disorders and apathy was based on the unified Parkinson’s disease rating scale. Reports of the behavioural changes are mainly based on interviews done by the same neuropsychologist at each follow up.
Results: Only two cognitive variables worsened (category fluency, total score of fluency). Age was a predictor of decline in executive functions. Depression improved whereas apathy and thought disorders worsened. Major behavioural changes were two transient aggressive impulsive episodes, one suicide, four suicide attempts, one permanent apathy, one transient severe depression, four psychoses (one permanent), and five hypomania (one permanent).
Conclusions: Comparing baseline, one year, and three year postoperative assessments, STN stimulation did not lead to global cognitive deterioration. Apathy scores mildly increased. Depression scores mildly improved. Behavioural changes were comparatively rare and mostly transient. Single case reports show the major synergistic effects of both medication and stimulation on mood and behaviour, illustrating the importance of a correct postoperative management.
Statistics from Altmetric.com
- STN DBS, subthalamic deep brain stimulation
- PD, Parkinson’s disease
- WCST, Wisconsin card sorting test
- MDRS, Mattis dementia rating scale
- BDI, Beck depression inventory
- UPDRS, unified Parkinson’s disease rating scale
Chronic bilateral subthalamic deep brain stimulation (STN DBS) may be used to treat patients with idiopathic Parkinson’s disease (PD) in whom long term pharmacological treatment has failed. Although this surgery has been shown to improve motor symptoms of PD,1,2 the effects of STN DBS on mood, cognitive functions, and behaviour are not well known and published results based on short term follow up are sometimes contradictory.3
Data concerning neuropsychological consequences of STN DBS usually show no global cognitive deterioration,1,4–7 except for small groups of elderly patients where cognitive decompensation is more frequent8,9 or in patients with preoperative cognitive decline.10 Comparisons between preoperative and postoperative (from 3 to 12 months after surgery) evaluations have shown minor improvements in frontal lobe function, as assessed by part B of the trail making test.4,11 On the other hand, mild cognitive impairments have also been reported, such as diminished verbal fluency,4,5,11 and delayed free recall (Grober and Buschke verbal memory test).6
Modest but significant improvement of depression has been shown after STN stimulation.4,12 Mania can occur after STN DBS.13–15 On the other hand, cases of depression—the opposite to mania in the spectrum of mood disorders—have been reported.16–19 In addition, abulia, apathy, or lack of motivation, have been described after STN DBS.8,9,12,20 Comparisons of preoperative and postoperative cognitive function or mood do not permit the determination of whether observed changes are related to the surgical intervention, to changes in medication, or to the stimulation itself. In addition, long term follow up must take into account the evolution of the disease. An alternative way to more specifically study the effects of STN DBS on cognition and mood is to compare the patients’ performances with their stimulators turned on or off. Studies using this methodology have shown that stimulation can improve some executive functions, with improved scores on the trail making test, random generation test, Wisconsin card sorting test and graphic series.5,21 Working memory was also improved with STN stimulation.5 On the other hand, visual conditional learning was impaired by STN stimulation and patients made a greater number of errors on the interference condition of the Stroop test with stimulation on.21 Acute changes of mood, specifically related to stimulation have also been reported. An assessment of acute subjective psychic effects of STN DBS has shown psychic stimulation, euphoria, and increased motivation, with decreased fatigue, anxiety, and tension when stimulators are turned on.22,23 Hilarity has been described related to an increase in stimulation parameters.24
The aim of this study was to assess the long term cognitive, mood, and behavioural effects of bilateral STN DBS in a large consecutive series of patients operated in the same centre.
From the whole series operated on so far, we examined the initial consecutive series of 77 parkinsonian patients (34 women) who had been operated on at least three years previously. Of this series, 70 have been followed up for three years. Among the seven excluded patients, four patients have been lost to follow up, two have died (one suicide, one death from unrelated disease), and one patient who developed a large frontal haematoma during surgery could not be evaluated. A systematic postoperative MRI showed four haematomas and three contusions. All seven patients had cognitive deterioration, either transient (2) or permanent (5). Two of these patients with permanent cognitive deteriorations could not be followed up. The mean (SD) age at surgery was 55 (8) and the mean (SD) duration of disease at surgery was 15 (5) years. The mean STN stimulation induced motor improvement was 63% one year after surgery and 59% three years after surgery (unified Parkinson’s disease rating scale (UPDRS) part III, on-stimulation/off-medication compared with preoperative off-medication), with a decrease in dopaminergic medication of 67% either one or three years after surgery.
Neuropsychological, mood, and behavioural assessments
Global cognitive efficiency was assessed with the Mattis dementia rating scale (MDRS).25 Executive functions were assessed with the Wisconsin card sorting test (WCST).26 We analysed the number of categories, the number of perseverative errors, the maintaining errors (that is, when the correct criterion is lost by the patient), and the total number of errors. Category and literal fluency (number of words in one minute) and graphic and motor series (score out of 10) were also assessed. A global frontal score was calculated from these four measures, with a maximum score of 50.27 Verbal learning was evaluated with the Grober and Buschke test.28 We prospectively considered the UPDRS part I29 scores to assess psychosis (thought disorders, item 2) and apathy (motivation/initiation, item 4). These scores range from 0 (without any symptoms), to 4 (severe symptoms). Mood was assessed with the Beck depression inventory (BDI),30 scores range from 0 to 59, divided into four categories: 0 (no depression, scores from 0 to 9), 1 (mild depression, scores from 10 to 17), 2 (moderate depression, scores from 18 to 24), and 3 (severe depression, scores from 25 to 59). This neuropsychological battery has been described in detail previously.4 We used different versions for the following tests: the WCST,5 fluency (categories and letters were changed following Cardebat equivalences,31) and for the Grober and Buschke learning test. The MDRS, the BDI, and the Grober and Buschke tests were not used preoperatively for the first patients, moreover the Grober and Buschke test can be used only in French speaking patients. In addition to the neuropsychological tests battery and UPDRS I, we also collected history based data concerning clear cut psychiatric events. The description of behavioural changes was mainly based on a systematic open interview done by the same neuropsychologist (CA) in all patients before surgery, at three months, one, two, and three years after surgery or when needed. All available information from the medical files and the caregivers were also taken into account. The diagnosis of hypomania has been carried out following DSM-IV criteria. Clinical diagnoses of apathy was based on the definition of Marin.32 Whereas the definition of apathy according to Marin excludes the presence of depression or dementia, the UPDRS I apathy item does not take into consideration comorbidity. Illustrative changes in mood or behaviour are presented as case reports.
Most patients were assessed without levodopa before surgery (83%). One year after surgery, all the patients have been evaluated with STN stimulation turned on, without levodopa in 94% of patients at one year and 69% at three years after surgery.
Analysis of variances for repeated measures were used to compare neuropsychological performances before, one year, and three years after STN DBS, and Pearson’s test for correlations. Post hoc comparisons (Fisher’s PLSD) were then used when analysis of variance was significant to compare data two by two. Because of the number of cognitive variables (24), we applied the Bonferroni correction, with a significance at p<0.01.
Table 1 lists the results of the neuropsychological test battery. Five variables changed significantly between preoperative and postoperative data (shown in bold type in the table). Category fluency was diminished on postoperative evaluation. Post hoc comparisons showed that the differences between preoperative score and one year (p<0.0001) and three years after surgery (p = 0.001) are significant (but not the comparison between one and three years after surgery). The total number of words cited by patients (category and literal fluency) varied also significantly between the three assessments. Post hoc comparisons showed that the scores are significantly worse one year (p = 0.0011) and three years (p = 0.0006) after surgery, when compared with the preoperative score, but the difference between one year and three years after surgery is not significant.
The BDI was significantly improved between the three assessments. Post hoc comparisons revealed that the comparison between preoperative and one year (p<0.0001) and three years (p = 0.004) were significant. The distribution of patients among the four categories of depression and the percentages of changes are shown in table 1 and table 2. The number of patients with severe depression at three years was the same as at baseline. Half of these patients with severe depression at three years were already severely depressed at baseline.
The UPDRS I scores of thought disorders significantly worsened with years (p<0.001). Post hoc comparisons revealed that differences were significant only between before surgery and three years after (p = 0.001), and between one and three years (p = 0.007). However, there were only three patients with a score ⩾2 before surgery and one year after surgery and only six patients three years after surgery, showing that only few patients had clinically relevant thought disorders. This increasing score, although significant, mainly represents increases between score 0 to 1, no score of 4 (representing psychosis) was noted at any assessments.
Apathy score changed significantly (p = 0.005), showing an increasing proportion of apathetic patients with time. Post hoc comparisons showed that only the difference between the score at baseline and at three years is significant (p = 0.001), although there was a trend for the comparison between baseline and one year after surgery (p = 0.055). The proportion of patients with a score ⩾2 doubled one year after surgery, from 8.7% before surgery to 17.4% one year after surgery and 24.6% three years after surgery.
Three other variables showed a tendency to be impaired after surgery: two subscores of the Mattis DRS: attention and initiation scores (respectively p = 0.017 and p = 0.036) and the frontal score (p = 0.042).
A significant correlation has been found between the decrease in the frontal score (p<0.001), the initiation subtest of the Mattis (p = 0.007), and the preoperative age of patients. The correlation between the preoperative age of patients and the item 2 of the UPDRS I, thought disorders tended to be significant (p = 0.023). None of these variables correlated with the preoperative Mattis score. Correlation between apathy and fluency (category) scores was significant one year after surgery (p = 0.002) and tended to be significant three years after surgery (p = 0.023).
Table 2 shows the patterns of changes for the main variables. Most of the patients remained cognitively stable by most measures. Among the 13 principal variables, the percentage of patients whose performance did not change from before to three years after surgery varied from 64% to 91% (see table 2). Only nine patients of 66 had a MDRS score below 130, the threshold for dementia, three years after surgery. Five of the nine had already scores below 130 before surgery. We can relate cognitive impairments to intracerebral bleeding or contusion in two patients. The two other patients showed a progressive deterioration of cognition between baseline and three years after surgery.
Concerning psychiatric events it is quite difficult to evaluate their percentage because of the non-standardised collection of data. After surgery, we noted four suicide attempts and one patient died by suicide. This occurred at different time points after surgery (2, 3, 5, 6, and 36 months).
Hypomania occurred in five patients, always during the first three months after surgery. Four of these patients recovered spontaneously an adapted behaviour within a few weeks, this behaviour persisted periodically during three years in one patient. Two patients had an episode of impulsive aggressive behaviour in the first postoperative days. One patient already had a tendency to react in an impulsive way before surgery. This episode happened after an increase in stimulation parameters and he was fully oriented throughout this episode. In the second patient, the behaviour occurred in association with postoperative delirium. At different times after surgery, four patients suffered from psychosis. One patient had a transient florid psychosis six weeks after surgery that required hospitalisation. Another patient had permanent psychosis, hallucinations or delusions without insight occurred in the two other ones. Two of these three last patients were demented. Severe depression requiring transient hospitalisation occurred in one patient.
Case report 1: apathy or loss of psychic autoactivation
A 56 year old man had a 24 year history of PD with severe akinesia off-drug and a craving behaviour. On levodopa (3700 mg daily) he was dyskinetic, and his relatives related hypersexuality. Evaluation revealed mild depression and no apathy. Three months postoperatively, his off-period motor signs and his dyskinesia were considerably improved. Levodopa was decreased to 1000 mg. However, the patient did not recognise his dramatic motor improvement in off-medication condition; in contrast, he claimed that he had globally worsened, complaining of fatigue, and worsened anxiety. He had no initiative, but enjoyed seeing his grandson. Hypersexuality had disappeared. Despite major apathy, his depression was only slightly worse than before surgery. Fluoxetine and amitriptyline treatment failed. Found motionless on his bed during hospitalisation, the patient was asked why he stayed in bed. He responded, “I am taking no medication. I am off”. After explanation that with STN stimulation activated he could move around without levodopa, he was profoundly doubtful, but did rise and walked normally on command. He described his state: “Something around me must move to turn me on. I need something to motivate me”. Over the next five years, medication and stimulation parameters remained stable. His motor state was identical at each visit. Although his apathy mildly improved and was stable at each annual visit, fatigue remained his main complaint. He was able to do everything, but he remained dependent on external stimuli.
Case report 2: depression sensitive to dopaminergic treatment
A 59 year old man had a 17 year history of akinetic-rigid PD with motor, and concurrent mood fluctuations on levodopa (2050 mg daily). Soon after disease onset, he developed mania with hypersexuality while on bromocriptine (75 mg). Withdrawing medication provoked depression. Preoperative depression was mild. At 12 month follow up, his treatment comprised: monopolar stimulation parameters—left 2.6 V, 60 μs, 130 Hz, right 2.4 V, 60 μs, 130 Hz, and levodopa (600 mg). With this treatment he had no residual motor symptoms and his mood was normal. Then, dopaminergic treatment was stopped. Six weeks later he reported depressed feelings that subsequently evolved to suicidal thoughts. He started antidepressant treatment with venlaflaxine (150 mg) and resumed low dose levodopa (200 mg). Stimulation parameters were not changed. Suicidal thoughts disappeared, but he remained depressed during the following three months. He stopped taking venlaflaxine, as he experienced no benefit, and resumed bromocriptine. His mood rapidly normalised on a small dose of dopaminergic treatment (15 mg bromocriptine and 200 mg of levodopa). Both his motor state and mood remained stable for the next two years with no further changes in treatment.
Case report 3: disappearance of mood fluctuations
A 61 year old woman had a 22 year history of severe PD with disabling motor fluctuations and drug induced dyskinesia. Preoperative levodopa was 1100 mg daily. Her mood fluctuated concurrently with her motor symptoms, and she received regular electroconvulsive therapy at six week intervals to improve her mood. Depression was absent at the time of surgery, but she felt deeply sad during each off period. Postoperatively the patient’s nonmotor fluctuations disappeared and mood was normal. She regained a very active social life during the following years. At her three year follow up, treatment included levodopa (450 mg), monopolar stimulation parameters—right side 3.6 V, 90 μs, 185 Hz and left side 3.2 V, 90 μs, 185 Hz. When stimulation was deactivated for motor evaluation, the patient immediately felt overwhelming sadness, dissolved into tears, and experienced a progressive reappearance of severe parkinsonism. When describing the impact of treatment, she said, “If stimulation is switched off, I am dead; when on, I am alive. With medication on top, it’s happiness and well being”.
Case report 4: postoperative honeymoon or hypomania
This 43 year old man had a 17 year history of PD with severe motor fluctuations on levodopa treatment (750 mg). The preoperative assessment found moderate depression. He viewed surgery as his only recourse because his quality of life was so diminished. At the postoperative three month assessment, he had major motor improvement and no need for antiparkinsonian medication. He described an independent, depression free life. He had, however, been hyperactive with very little sleep during those three months. He said, “I never before had such energy, neither motor nor intellectually. I rediscovered the joie de vivre, pleasure, laughter”. He compared this state with his honeymoon at the onset of action of levodopa: “With drugs, I had lost control; it was not joy but a drunkenness, a very short euphoria, which was not my own...” At the 12 month assessment he remained medication free with the same stimulation parameters. He described his immediate postoperative euphoric state: “It was too much. I had too much energy in me. I wasn’t able to sleep for three months, I had to keep moving all the time...but it felt so good to be euphoric, it was like a liberation after 17 years of sickness”.
This analysis of long term follow up data suggests that there is no global deterioration in neuropsychological function attributable to bilateral STN DBS itself. This confirms previous reports with shorter follow up durations.1,4,5,11 Postoperative mild cognitive decline related to the surgical procedure is mostly transient. Permanent cognitive decline related to the surgical procedure occurred in five patients in our series. A very progressive decline occurred in two other patients, probably related to the evolution of the neurodegenerative process. One of the two demented patients also exhibited psychotic behaviour. Age of patients was significantly correlated with the decrease in frontal score, in keeping with the more frequent incidence of parkinsonian frontosubcortical dementia with age.33–35
Some limitations of this study need to be pointed out. Behaviour has not been assessed prospectively using psychiatric scales. Nevertheless, the same neuropsychologist has seen all patients at all the follow up times, with a complete interview, which provides a strong database. PD is a neuropsychiatric disease and moreover psychiatric complications of levodopa treatment are not rare36,37 Except for the cognitive deterioration occurring in some patients related to neurosurgical complications and for a slight increase in apathy, major psychiatric events were comparatively rare. However, as the study lacks a control group it is difficult to draw any firm conclusions concerning the frequency of such complications related to the treatment. Another problem is the test-re-test effect. Indeed, a learning effect could have masked a deterioration in some of the neuropsychological tests. Nevertheless, we used different versions when possible. The proportion of patients with increasing scores with time did not exceed 13%. Nevertheless we cannot totally exclude some learning effects.
The diminished verbal fluency described previously4,5,8,9 is corroborated at long term follow up. It seems to occur immediately after surgery, with no further deterioration over time, thus it could be non-specifically related to surgery itself or to decrease in medication that is maximal immediately after surgery. Although this change in fluency is significant, its magnitude is minor. Verbal fluency tasks may be less externally guided than other executive tests.5 In our study, the observed verbal fluency deficit could be related to a decrease in self activation. In other words, it may be a result of the increased apathy commonly seen in association with the decrease in dopaminergic treatment after STN DBS.9,20,38 Indeed there is a correlation between high levels of apathy and low category fluency scores one year after surgery, and a trend for correlation three years after surgery.
One of the most intriguing symptoms observed after surgery was apathy. This apathy, which often is expressed as a fatigue by the patient, is best illustrated by case report 1. The patients are neither depressed nor demented. When discussing with them, they express they do not feel sad, have many plans and that they wish to do a lot of things, but that they feel tired and have difficulties in starting any actions. The caregivers typically report that although they are able to do everything, in fact they stay sitting in a chair all day long without taking any initiative. When told to do a job however, they will carry out this task, and can enjoy doing them afterwards. This seems to correspond to the syndrome described by Laplane in basal ganglia lesions and called loss of psychic self activation.39,40 This syndrome obviously escapes to detection using the neuropsychological test battery that we applied except for fluency as discussed above. How can we explain this apathy? Apathy is associated with lesions of the limbic basal ganglia loop, mainly projecting to the anterior cingulate cortex. Total loss of initiative was described after bilateral cingulate vascular lesions (“akinetic mutism”), or bilateral GPi lesions (“loss of psychic self activation”). The decrease in striatal dopaminergic activity can also lead to an apathetic state such as in PD or after neuroleptic treatment. This suggests that apathy can be improved by increasing dopaminergic activity in the limbic basal ganglia loop, or by modulating this loop. Our study shows that parkinsonian patients can develop apathy after bilateral STN DBS effective on off-period motor function. Therefore, STN stimulation may be less effective than a dopaminergic treatment to control the parkinsonian apathetic state. Actually, dopaminergic drugs are known to improve the parkinsonian apathy41 and an acute levodopa challenge has been shown to be more effective on the subjective psychic stimulation than bilateral STN stimulation.42 This finding can help the practical postoperative management of patients with bilateral STN DBS. A state of apathy should be carefully searched and preferentially treated by increasing or resuming dopamine drugs, even if this treatment is not required to control parkinsonian motor symptoms. In that case, dopaminergic agonists drug are generally preferred to levodopa to avoid the risk of dyskinesia.43
In this series there was a mild but significant improvement in depression, even three years after surgery, confirming similar findings in the immediate postoperative period.4,12 It seems, however, that while patients do indeed feel better in the early postoperative period, over time their mood scores tend to progressively rise close to preoperative values. This favourable effect on mood has already been shown after short term STN stimulation.24,42 Short duration changes in mood have not been evaluated in our study. Mood frequently fluctuates along with motor swings.44 In single cases mood fluctuations disappeared with STN stimulation (case report 3). Future studies should investigate the effect of subthalamic stimulation on mood fluctuations using more appropriate tests.
Although average changes in mood were not impressive, in some patients major changes in initiative, mood, or behaviour occurred, as illustrated in case reports. These changes were mostly transient and could be influenced by changes in medication or stimulation.
In the literature, some single cases of mania,13–15 or depression16–19 have been reported after STN DBS. These opposite changes are only seemingly contradictory. Hypomania or mania generally occurs in the immediate postoperative period as in our cases and can be explained by additive psychotropic effects of STN stimulation and dopaminergic treatment.42,45 Decreasing long acting dopamine agonist drugs before surgery may help prevent postoperative hypomania. Depression on the other hand can appear with a longer latency and can be related to decrease in dopaminergic treatment and the loss of the antidepressant effect of levodopa in the same way as for apathy.41,42,45 Adapting medication and stimulation parameters would avoid such complications in the long term.46
The occurrence of impulsive aggressive behaviour and suicide attempts is intriguing. This is reminiscent of the premature responses described after STN lesioning in rats.47 In some patients, especially those with psychiatric history,18 changing the STN neuronal activity by DBS may trigger an impulsive behaviour. Aggressive behaviour has been explained by current diffusion to the hypothalamus by other authors.48
Considering the architecture of the cortical-subcortical circuitry,49 several data suggest that STN DBS may influence the associative and limbic loops in addition to the motor loop.5,21,23,24,42,45 Although this study did not include a comprehensive assessment of all aspects of cognitive function, the comparative lack of cognitive changes observed on long term postoperative follow up suggests that the influence of STN DBS on the associative loop is minor and much less important than its effect on the motor loop.
In conclusion, long term bilateral STN stimulation does not seem to have a global significant effect on neuropsychological functions and mood despite its important effect on off-period motor function. However, individual cases may exhibit pronounced changes in mood and behaviour. The risk of psychiatric complications can be reduced by a careful management of pharmacological and stimulation treatments.
Competing interests: PK, AB, and PP have been reimbursed by Medtronic, the manufacturer of the implanted material for attending several conferences. AB is the director of the research laboratory U318 at INSERM France, which receives from Medtronic an unrestricted education grant. PP has received an honorarium from Medtronic for expert work.
If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.