Table 2

Neurological and neuropsychological data, and quality of life for the three groups at baseline and 3 mFU

Group-neg (n=8)Group-mix (n=8)Group-pos (n=14)F/χ2p Value
Neurological data
UPDRS-IIIMed onBaseline16.00±4.1420.88±7.3623.57±12.752.333b0.312
UPDRS-IIIMed offBaseline39.88±7.9740.00±11.8946.79±16.090.985a0.386
Stim on and med off3 mFU28.63±10.47**28.13±9.13*24.77±18.11***§0.232a0.795
LEDD (mg)Baseline900.75±576.63806.25±371.63709.86±340.600.534a0.593
3 mFU479.58±299.94*250.42±243.01**326.36±116.41**2.000b0.368
Neuropsychological data
Digit span forwards T-scoresBaseline58.13±9.4657.86±9.25§53.86±11.260.581a0.566
3 mFU52.50±13.3153.25±5.8749.79±12.590.280a0.758
Digit span backward T-scoresBaseline49.00±11.5943.43±6.13§47.14±9.350.677a0.517
3 mFU49.13±12.6841.88±19.7845.15±7.160.866b0.649
Verbal fluency (letters) T-scoresBaseline54.58±8.7547.67±9.06§49.93±10.251.050a0.364
3 mFU47.87±6.88*46.63±9.9550.02±10.950.333a0.720
Brief test of attention raw scoresBaseline11.88±4.129.86±3.53§10.14±4.690.535a0.592
3 mFU9.00±4.1411.25±3.0610.07±4.830.560a0.578
Quality of life
PDQ-39Baseline47.09±19.4634.71±16.0533.58±13.552.001a0.155
3 mFU43.17±14.01†,‡,§20.44±9.28†*21.56±12.06‡**9.143a0.001
  • Values represent means±SD. p Values by a ANOVA (F) or b Kruskall–Wallis H-test (χ2).

  • *Represent significant changes for paired samples t test for UPDRS-III (baseline med off vs 3 mFU stim on/med off), LEDD, PDQ-39 and verbal fluency data within a group, *<0.05, **<0.01, ***<0.001.

  • †Bonferroni posthoc test: significant difference between group-neg and group-mix.

  • ‡Bonferroni posthoc test: significant difference between group-neg and group-pos.

  • §Missing data for one patient.

  • N, number of patients; group-neg, subjective outcome negative; group-mix, subjective outcome mixed; group-pos, subjective outcome positive; med off, medication off; stim on, stimulation on; 3 mFU, 3 months follow-up; UPDRS, Unified Parkinson's Disease Rating Scale-III; LEDD, l-dopa equivalent daily dose; PDQ-39, Parkinson's Disease Questionnaire-39.

  • Test score range: UPDRS-III, 0–108, higher scores equal more impairment; digit span forwards, 0–100, higher scores equal better performance; digit span backwards, 0–100, higher scores equal better performance; verbal fluency (letters), 0–100, higher scores equal better performance; brief test of attention, 0–20, higher scores equal better performance; PDQ-39, 0–100, higher scores equal more impaired quality of life.