Section Q
Challenges to understanding spatial patterns of disease: Philosophical alternatives to logical positivism

https://doi.org/10.1016/0277-9536(92)90351-PGet rights and content

Abstract

Most studies of disease distribution, in medical geography and other related disciplines, have been empirical in nature and rooted in the assumptions of logical positivism. However, some of the more newly articulated philosophies of the social sciences, and of social theory, have much to add in the understanding of the processes and mechanisms underlying disease distribution. This paper represents a plea for creative synthesis between logical positivism and realism or structuration, and uses specific examples to suggest how disease distribution, as a surface phenomenon, can be explained using deeper analysis.

References (22)

  • J.M. May

    The Ecology of Human Disease

    (1958)
  • Cited by (16)

    • Replacing positivism in medical geography

      2005, Social Science and Medicine
    • Etiology of limited transmission diseases among drug users: Does recent migration magnify the risk of sharing injection equipment?

      2000, Social Science and Medicine
      Citation Excerpt :

      The other five variables were included as a means of incorporating various forms of mobility that have been considered in the literature (physically homeless vs. not homeless, the median split of number of days living at current address, incarcerated vs. not incarcerated in the last 30 days, unemployed vs. other circumstances and perceiving oneself as homeless vs. not homeless). Although the perceived homelessness variable is inherently subjective, as a phenomenological question, it may present important experiential data pertaining to postmigration adjustment (Mayer, 1992). Because this is largely an exploratory study, the risk behavior was recoded from a continuous variable (number of times shared injection equipment with someone else in the last 30 days) to a dichotomous variable (shared any injection equipment with someone else in the last 30 days) for performing both modeling approaches.

    • Our sense of Snow: The myth of John Snow in medical geography

      2000, Social Science and Medicine
      Citation Excerpt :

      Do medical cartographers actually state that causation and proof exist in their maps, or do the map interpreters project those expectations? Recent questions about the presentation of the story of Broad Street outbreak in the medical geography literature (McLeod 1998a,b; Rip et al., 1998) also fit into the debate on the nature of the discipline (see Bennett, 1991; Mayer, 1992; Kearns and Joseph, 1993; Dorn and Laws, 1994; Kearns, 1994; Mayer and Meade, 1994; Del Casino and Dorn, 1998 for some examples). Some authors have argued that the traditional concerns of medical geography — the geographic study of disease and of accessibility, utilization, and provision of health care — are rooted in spatial theory, and as such miss the complexity of human experiences with health, illness and healing by hiding behind the simplicity of quantitative explanation.

    View all citing articles on Scopus
    View full text