OBJECTIVE Although both orthostatic hypotension and urinary incontinence have been reported in a number of parkinsonian syndromes, such as Parkinson’s disease (PD), multiple system atrophy (MSA), dementia with Lewy bodies (DLB), corticobasal degeneration (CBD), and progressive supranuclear palsy (PSP), differences in the evolution of these features have not been studied systematically in pathologically confirmed cases.
METHODS 77 cases with pathologically confirmed parkinsonian syndromes (PD, n=11; MSA, n=15; DLB, n=14; CBD, n=13; PSP, n=24), collected up to 1994, formed the basis for a multicentre clinicopathological study organised by the NINDS to improve the differential diagnosis of parkinsonian disorders. The present study determined the time course—that is, latency to onset and duration from onset to death, of symptomatic orthostatic hypotension, and urinary incontinence in the NINDS series. Furthermore, the diagnostic validity of a predefined latency to onset within 1 year of disease onset of symptomatic orthostatic hypotension or urinary incontinence was analysed.
RESULTS Significant group differences for latency, but not duration, of symptomatic orthostatic hypotension and urinary incontinence were found. Latencies to onset of either feature were short in patients with MSA, intermediate in patients with DLB, CBD, and PSP, and long in those with PD. Symptomatic orthostatic hypotension occurring within the first year after disease onset predicted MSA in 75% of cases; early urinary incontinence was less predictive for MSA (56%).
CONCLUSION Latency to onset, but not duration, of symptomatic orthostatic hypotension or urinary incontinence differentiates PD from other parkinsonian syndromes, particularly MSA.
- orthostatic hypotension
- urinary incontinence
Statistics from Altmetric.com
If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.
Symptomatic orthostatic hypotension often occurs in Parkinson’s disease (PD)1 2 and multiple system atrophy (MSA),1 3 4 a common cause of atypical parkinsonism.5 It may also be present in dementia with Lewy bodies (DLB).6 Other parkinsonian syndromes including progressive supranuclear palsy (PSP)7 8 and corticobasal degeneration (CBD)9 are less commonly associated with symptomatic orthostatic hypotension. Its presence alone in a patient with parkinsonism, therefore, seems to contribute little towards a differential diagnosis. The temporal evolution of symptomatic orthostatic hypotension has never been explored systematically in parkinsonian disorders. If present, such time course differences may improve the diagnostic accuracy of clinicians facing parkinsonian patients. Indeed, a recent clinicopathological study from the United Kingdom Parkinson’s Disease Society Brain Bank reported early severe orthostatic hypotension in patients with confirmed MSA than in patients with PD; however, latencies and durations of both features were not determined.10 In the present study, we retrospectively analysed the temporal evolution of symptomatic orthostatic hypotension in patients with postmortem validated PD, MSA, DLB, PSP, and CBD. Furthermore, we determined whether the early appearance of symptomatic orthostatic hypotension within 1 year of onset of disease improves diagnostic accuracy of these disorders as measured by sensitivity and positive predictive value. Finally, for comparison we analysed the time course of urinary incontinence, another (partly) autonomic feature, in these patients.
SAMPLE AND DATA COLLECTION
Seventy seven cases with pathologically confirmed parkinsonian syndromes (PD, n=11; MSA, n=15; DLB, n=14; PSP, n=24; CBD, n=13) collected up to 1994, formed the basis for a multicentre clinicopathological study organised by the National Institute of Neurological Disorders (NINDS) to improve differential diagnosis of parkinsonian disorders. Cases with excellent clinicopathological documentation sufficient for the purpose of the present study were selected from the research and clinical neuropathological files of seven medical centres in four countries (Austria, France, United Kingdom, and the United States). The cases met the neuropathological NINDS criteria for the diagnosis of PSP and related disorders11 and Kosaka’s criteria for Lewy body disease.12 Orthostatic hypotension was defined as a symptomatic systolic blood pressure drop of 20 mm Hg within 3 minutes of standing.13 Symptoms of orthostatic hypotension included dizziness, presyncope, and (rarely) syncopal attacks. Blood pressure was recorded at bedside; formal cardiovascular function tests were available in few patients and therefore were not analysed. Urinary incontinence implied partial or complete involuntary bladder emptying in the absence of secondary causes such as outflow obstruction. Because formal urodynamic studies were not always performed, secondary causes may have been present in a minority of patients. Time to onset (months) and duration (months) until death of orthostatic hypotension and urinary incontinence were determined by retrospective chart review (GKW, IL).
Box plots were applied to determine the distribution of latency and duration data across the groups. Non-parametric statistics (Kruskal-Wallis and Mann Whitney U test) were then used to identifiy significant group differences. Finally, diagnostic accuracy of a predefined latency (urinary incontinence or symptomatic orthostatic hypotension occurring within 1 year from onset of disease) was evaluated by analysing the sensitivity, specificity, and positive predictive value of such predefined latency for the diagnosis of each parkinsonian disorder.
Orthostatic hypotension was not recorded in patients with CBD; it rarely occurred in DLB (15%), occasionally in PSP, (45%) and often in patients with PD (78%) and those with MSA (87%) (p<0.0001). Latencies were intermediate in patients with MSA, DLB, or PSP compared with long latencies in patients with PD (table 2). Significant overall group differences for latency, but not duration of orthostatic hypotension, were found. Direct group comparisons disclosed significantly longer latencies in patients with PD than in patients with MSA or PSP (table 2).
The frequency of urinary incontinence was similar in all patient groups ranging between 62% and 87% (PD, 82%; MSA, 87%; DLB, 64%; PSP, 75%; and CBD, 62%; (p>0.05)). Latencies were short in patients with MSA, intermediate in patients with DLB, PSP, or CBD, and long in patients with PD (table 2). Significant overall group differences for latency, but not duration, of urinary dysfunction were seen. Direct group comparisons disclosed significantly shorter latencies in patients with MSA compared with those with PD, CBD, or PSP (table 2).
EARLY ORTHOSTATIC HYPOTENSION AND URINARY INCONTINENCE
One year latencies for symptomatic orthostatic hypotension achieved poor diagnostic sensitivity for all parkinsonian disorders, and were highest in MSA (20%) followed by PSP (4%). Similarly, positive predictive values were higher in patients with MSA (75%) than (25%) patients with PSP. Specificity was optimal in MSA (98%) and suboptimal in PSP (94%). No patient with PD, CBD, or DLB developed symptomatic orthostatic hypotension within the first year of onset of disease. Diagnostic sensitivity for early urinary incontinence was similarly poor compared with symptomatic orthostatic hypotension, and was highest in MSA (33%) followed by DLB (14%) and PSP (8%) (table3). The positive predictive value for early urinary incontinence was slightly less in the patients with MSA and poor or absent in the other patient groups. Specificity was generally suboptimal, in the order of 85% to 94%.
This clinicopathological study is the first to investigate both frequency and time course of symptomatic orthostatic hypotension and urinary incontinence in a range of postmortem confirmed parkinsonian syndromes including PD, MSA, DLB, CBD, and PSP. Although we recognise the methodological limitations of our study, in particular selection bias toward more severely affected cases, irregular follow up, and lack of functional urodynamic and formal autonomic function testing in some patients, the following conclusions seem to emerge from our study: onset latencies of symptomatic orthostatic hypotension and urinary incontinence distinguished PD and atypical parkinsonian syndromes. Latencies were long in patients with PD, extending for more than 10 years. Except for CBD, they were significantly shorter in atypical parkinsonian syndromes, approaching 1–2 years in patients with MSA. Consistent with this finding, a 1 year latency cut off for urinary incontinence and orthostatic hypotension predicted MSA in three of four (75%) patients satisfying this criterion. Five of nine patients with MSA with orthostatic symptoms had received levodopa treatment, coadministered with amantadine, bromocriptine, or selegiline in three patients. Although dopaminergic therapy may have triggered or excacerbated orthostatic hypotension in these patients, in the remaining four patients without antiparkinsonian drugs orthostatic symptoms were clearly related to disease. There was one patient (4%) with PSP with documented symptomatic orthostatic hypotension present from onset of disease and unrelated to drug intake. Generally, the falls in blood pressure seemed milder in PSP than in MSA. However, due to insufficient source data, this could not be analysed systematically. Neither the presence alone nor duration of orthostatic hypotension and urinary incontinence were helpful for differential diagnosis.
Previous studies of neurogenic orthostatic hypotension have largely been devoted to PD and MSA. Bannister and Oppenheimer, in a clinicopathologcial study, first reported that both disorders may account for symptomatic orthostatic hypotension in association with central autonomic failure.1 These authors highlighted several clinical features that may be useful for differential diagnosis including young age at onset in patients with PD as well as multiple neurological signs in patients with MSA. Urinary incontinence received little attention in their series, and differences in the time course of orthostatic hypotension were not reported. Neuropathologically, Bannister and Oppenheimer observed marked degeneration of the intermediolateral cell columns of the spinal cord in patients with MSA and those with PD. Lesions were more widespread in MSA affecting the thalamus and hypothalamus as well, and were associated with Lewy body deposition in PD. Almost 20 years later characteristic glial cytoplasmic inclusions were reported by Papp and Lantos in a large number of brains from patients with MSA.14 15
Recent studies confirmed that orthostatic hypotension is usually mild in PD10 16; however, a small subgroup of patients seem to have more severe cardiovascular autonomic failure of peripheral origin.17 Although the average severity of orthostatic hypotension seems different in large cohorts of PD and MSA,10 this information is of limited diagnostic value for the clinician facing a person with parkinsonism and autonomic failure. Non-invasive investigations have been reported to be useful in distinguishing between MSA and PD in their early stages. The response to clonidine, which is dependent on central stimulation of α2-adrenergic receptors, is impaired in MSA but preserved in PD.18 Food causes a smaller fall in supine blood pressure in PD than MSA.19 In general, dopaminergic therapy may exacerbate or trigger symptomatic orthostatic hypotension in parkinsonian patients. Due to the retrospective nature of our study we were unable to consider this issue systematically. Autonomic failure associated with orthostatic hypotension has been recognised as a possible manifestation of DLB,20 a disorder typically associated with widespread deposition of Lewy bodies also affecting pathways of the autonomic nervous system. Given the considerable clinicopathological overlap of PD and DLB some of the patients with PD and severe autonomic failure reported by Bannisteret al 1may have had DLB. Severe autonomic dysfunction seems to be uncommon in PSP7 and CBD21; this impression was confirmed by our present study.
Our data demonstrate for the first time highly significant differences in the time course of symptomatic orthostatic hypotension in parkinsonian syndromes. Symptomatic orthostatic hypotension occurring within 1 year of onset of disease predicted MSA in 75% of patients. In our series, patients with PD or atypical parkinsonian syndromes other than MSA—that is, DLB, PSP, and CBD, rarely or never developed symptomatic orthostatic hypotension during the first year of onset of disease. Therefore, the early development of orthostatic hypotension in patients with parkinsonism strongly suggests MSA.
Bladder dysfunction has again received more attention in PD and MSA than other parkinsonian disorders. In MSA, urinary symptoms result from a combination of detrusor hyperreflexia and urethral sphincter weakness.22 Urethral or anal sphincter EMGs often disclose denervation resulting from the degeneration of Onuf’s nucleus in the sacral cord.23 24 In PD, urinary frequency and urgency resulting from detrusor hyperreflexia are common; however, urethral sphincter function is preserved.25 These pathophysiological differences probably account for the early appearance of urinary incontinence in MSA compared with PD. Data on urological symptoms in atypical parkinsonian syndromes other than MSA are rare. A Japanese study of nine patients with PSP showed severe abnormalities similar to MSA, including detrusor hyperreflexia, detrusor-sphincter dyssynergia, and sphincter denervation.26 A minority of patients with PSP also develop mild to moderate degrees of denervation affecting the external anal sphincter.27
Our comparative study for the first time showed marked time course differences of urinary incontinence between atypical parkinsonian syndromes, particularly MSA and PD. Similar to orthostatic hypotension, early appearance of urinary incontinence within the first year of disease onset suggested MSA although sensitivity and positive predictive values were suboptimal. Sensitivity and positive predictive values for a diagnosis of MSA increased at later time points; however, specificity dropped markedly (data not shown).
Taken together, our data show the usefulness of time course differences for symptomatic orthostatic hypotension and urinary incontinence in the early differential diagnosis of parkinsonian syndromes, particularly PD and MSA. Development of either feature during the first year after disease onset in a patient with parkinsonism is highly suggestive of MSA.