Statistics from Altmetric.com
Alien hand syndrome (AHS) is characterised by abnormal motor behaviour of the contralateral upper limb, which is subjectively experienced as involuntary or alien induced.1 The affected hand often shows a grasp reflex and an instinctive grasp reaction, as well as elements of “magnetic apraxia” associated with frontal lobe damage. The most common frontal type of AHS is repeatedly observed in patients with lesions in the supplementary motor area, anterior cingulate gyrus, medial prefrontal cortex, and anterior corpus callosum. Involuntary uncontrolled movements in AHS usually remain unchanged or improve gradually over periods of varying length. A paroxysmal form of alien hand syndrome has been described very rarely. In these exceptional cases, focal epileptic seizures were suspected to be the pathophysiological substrate for paroxysmal alien limb phenomena.2,3
We report a 61 year old right handed man with a paroxysmal form of alien hand syndrome resulting from an ischaemic lesion within the rostral part of the right cingulate motor area (CMA) (fig 1A). Short episodes with typical spontaneous involuntary movements of his left hand (groping, scratching, grasping) developed suddenly four days before patient’s admission to our ward. At that time, normal glycaemia and a transient increase in blood pressure (200/100 mm Hg) were observed. A neurological examination revealed normal findings with the exception of positive grasp reflex on the affected upper limb. Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) on the same day disclosed circumscribed hyperintense lesion with a 12 mm diameter in the right anterior cingulate cortex. Cerebrospinal fluid examination and an interictal EEG was normal. All “alien hand” episodes started and terminated suddenly; they occurred every 15 minutes and their duration was one to three minutes. The patient was fully conscious during the seizures. He experienced the abnormal motor behaviour of his left hand as involuntary. He was unable to control these hand movements despite great effort. The abnormal movements were repeatedly directed towards external stimuli. A gradual increase in seizure frequency was observed in subsequent days, and discrete myoclonic jerks and slight tonic posturing of the left upper extremity were added to the typical hand automatisms. An FDG-PET investigation showed focal hypermetabolism of the right CMA (corresponding precisely to the structural MRI lesion) and repeated video-EEG monitoring clearly revealed the ictal epileptic mechanism of the “alien hand” seizures (fig 1, panels B and C). A neuropsychological examination revealed no speech problems or problems with bimanual coordination. The paroxysmal complex motor activities of the left upper limb completely disappeared immediately after antiepileptic drug treatment (levetiracetam) was begun. Control MRI (done after three days, two weeks, and three months) confirmed an ischaemic aetiology of the structural lesion.
Studies on primates, and increasing evidence in humans, support the notion that the anterior cingulate cortex is strongly involved in the preparation and execution of movements. A specific role may be played by an area that encompasses the ventral bank of the cingulate sulcus and is located just behind and in front of the vertical plane that passes through the anterior commissure (VCA). This region corresponds to the simian rostral cingulate motor area (rCMA); in humans it contains gigantopyramidal neurones which resemble the Betz pyramidal cells of the primary motor cortex. The projections of this area 24c (rCMA) target mainly the rostral portion of the SMA (medial area 6aβ).4 Interestingly, electrical stimulation of this area, undertaken recently in one epileptic patient, provoked “an irresistible urge to grasp something, …, accompanied by a wandering arm movement contralateral to the stimulation side”.5 Based on this finding, an engagement of CMA in compulsive goal directed motor behaviour in humans was suggested. Our present observation clearly demonstrated that even limited impairment of the rostral part of the CMA may produce the clinical alien hand syndrome. It is noteworthy that the structural lesion in AHS patients often encroaches on the supplementary motor area and the middle section of the corpus callosum, and it is therefore difficult to define the precise involvement of the anterior cingulate cortex.
Unequivocal proof of the epileptic origin of paroxysmal AHS represents another important aspect of the present case report. To date, only three patients with an epileptogenic lesion within the frontomedial cortex manifesting with paroxysmal alien limb phenomena have been analysed in the literature. In the light of the seriously limited published sources, our findings provide evidence of an underlying epileptic mechanism in paroxysmal AHS. The ictal EEG pattern in our subject was obtained on the third day after his admission, when a slight tonic posturing of the left upper extremity had already been added to the typical “alien hand” automatisms (fig 1C). The spreading of the ictal activity from rCMA to premotor and motor cortical areas resulting in the additional tonic phenomena is highly probable. The ictal EEG recordings from the date of the patient’s admission with pure ictal “alien hand” signs revealed only very discrete non-specific changes in the central and right paracentral region (Cz and C4). In this case, an underlying ictal activity in the “hidden” lesional/perilesional region is strongly anticipated. But absolute certainty that the rCMA is solely responsible for the paroxysmal “alien hand” syndrome could only be drawn from invasive EEG investigation or electrical cortical stimulation. This treatment was not necessary for clinical reasons and thus was not undertaken in our patient.
In conclusion, rostral CMA very probably plays a crucial role in the production of ictal automatic motor behaviour of the contralateral hand. This finding may further implicate the participation of this part of the caudal anterior cingulate cortex in the genesis of ictal limb automatisms in epileptic patients.
We are grateful to Drs J Vaníček and K Bolčák for their neuroimaging contributions.
Competing interests: none declared
If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.