Article Text

Download PDFPDF

A 15-year prospective longitudinal study of disease progression in patients with HTLV-1 associated myelopathy in the UK
  1. Fabiola Martin1,2,
  2. Alexandra Fedina1,
  3. Silva Youshya2,
  4. Graham P Taylor1,2
  1. 1National Centre for Human Retrovirology, Imperial College Healthcare NHS Trust, St Mary's Hospital, London, UK
  2. 2Section of Infectious Diseases, Faculty of Medicine, Imperial College, London, UK
  1. Correspondence to Dr Fabiola Martin, National Centre for Human Retrovirology, Imperial College Healthcare NHS Trust, St Mary's Hospital, London W2 1NY, UK; f.martin{at}imperial.ac.uk

Abstract

Background The natural history of HTLV-1-associated myelopathy (HAM) has been mainly described in HTLV-1 endemic countries such as Japan, Brazil and Martinique.

Objectives The authors describe the natural history of the largest cohort of patients with HAM living in the UK from 1993 to 2007.

Methods Prospective, longitudinal study comparing clinical and virological outcome between first and last clinical visit. Incidence and cause of death were documented and the mortality calculated.

Results 48 patients were included: 79.2% were female, 79.2% were of Afro-Caribbean origin, and 83.3% acquired HTLV-1 through breastfeeding or unprotected heterosexual intercourse. The mean age of onset was 46 years. The median durations from onset of symptoms to diagnosis and to last follow-up were 2 and 11.6 years. The median time of follow-up was 3.8 years. The most common first recalled symptom was unilateral leg weakness. The median times from onset to unilateral, bilateral walking aid and frame or a wheelchair were 11, 11.2, 11.3 and 18 years. The overall average deterioration in timed walk in patients whose need for aid did not change was 2 s/10 m/year. Three patients progressed rapidly and were unable to walk within 2 years. Six patients were slow/non-progressors. The mortality was 2.4/100 person year follow-up. The median HTLV-1 viral load remained unchanged at 14%.

Conclusions HAM is a slowly progressing chronic disease. Timed walk deteriorates by 2 s/10 m/year, and patients remain ambulant for 10 years but become wheelchair-dependent a decade later. HTLV-1 viral load remains high and unchanged over time regardless of clinical progression.

  • Anticonvulsants
  • HTLV1
  • myelopathy
  • pain
  • spasticity

Statistics from Altmetric.com

Background

HTLV-1 associated myelopathy (HAM) is a chronic non-remitting spastic paraparesis of insidious onset with lower-limb weakness, spasticity and generalised hyper-reflexia accompanied by bladder/bowel dysfunction and lower-back pain in patients with positive HTLV-1 antibody. Cranial nerves and upper limbs are usually unaffected.1–4 HTLV-1 infection is not a ubiquitous infection but endemic in the West Indies, Brazil, Japan, West Africa, Romania and Iran (Necula A. Screening for Anti-HTLV in Romania—1999 to 2005—Update. 19 May 2005. Ref Type: Unpublished Work).5–15

WHO diagnostic criteria of HAM defining three levels of ascertainment for HAM diagnosis: definite, probable and possible, excluding all conditions that could mimic HAM,16 make geographically and genetically separate definite HAM cohorts comparable.

Studies of HAM prior to 1996 described progression during the first year followed by a plateau phase.1 17–20 Recent studies, in both Japanese and Afro-Caribbean cohorts, describe a more insidious onset with delayed diagnosis and continuous progression.4 21 A more rapid onset and progression of HAM has been reported in patients transfused with HTLV-1 infected blood22 and in children.23 Non- or slow progressing patients with HAM have not been defined so far, although patients with stable HAM have been described previously.

A Japanese study of 64 patients with HAM followed up for 10 years showed deterioration of gait, muscle power and bladder function in 56%, 41% remained unchanged, and 3% of the patients improved. The rate of disease progression was associated with a higher HTLV-1 viral load and older age of onset (>65 years) as well as a history of blood transfusion. This study did not provide any details of the presenting symptom, presence or absence of pain or bladder/bowel symptoms, walking aid usage at baseline, time to progression to additional aid or the mortality.21

In 2006, a group in Martinique published longitudinal data on 123 Afro-Caribbean patients with HAM. The mean time from onset to first clinic visit was 5.3 years, while the duration of HAM at final follow-up was 13 years. At last review, 81.3% had started using at least one walking stick, 56.9% had started using two walking sticks, while 36.6% had become wheelchair-dependent, with median times from onset of HAM to the use of these aids of 6, 13 and 21 years respectively. Wheelchair usage started after 25 years of disease if the age of onset was <50 years but after only 14 years if age at onset was ≥50 years, and this progression was significantly earlier in those patients with an HTLV-1 viral load of >105 HTLV-1 DNA copies/106 PBMCs. Gender, history of blood transfusion and initial symptom (gait impairment vs urinary disturbance) did not affect the disease course. The authors concluded that motor disability worsens throughout the disease course and that faster early deterioration predicts the rate of progression in the long-term.4 Of the 22 deaths (17.8%), 19 (86%) were attributed to HAM, with pneumonia and nephritis/sepsis as the dominant causes.

Two studies, from Brazil and Peru, have reported increased mortality in patients with rapid progression to immobility within 2 years of the onset of HAM.24 25

In the UK, an HTLV non-endemic country, an estimated 20 000 persons are infected with HTLV-1, of which 3% will develop HTLV-1-associated myelopathy.26 The majority of diagnosed patients are managed at the National Centre for Human Retrovirology.

The natural history of this unique cohort has not been described and may differ from other populations due to genetic, transmission and environmental factors. The aims of this prospective study were to describe the natural history and identify predictors of disease progression in this UK cohort of patients with HAM.

Methods

Subjects and methods

For this observational natural history study, data were collected prospectively on all patients with HAM who attended the National Centre for Human Retrovirology (NCHR) in London from July 1993 to April 2007. Patients were followed up three monthly. Data were originally recorded in Excel, and in addition all notes were hand-searched for missing data. Patients were excluded if they were followed up for less than 3 months, had other confounding conditions or were coinfected with HIV. All comparisons are between the first and last clinic visits.

The descriptive variables were gender, ethnicity, perceived risk factor for HTLV-1 infection, first recalled symptom, age at onset, age at diagnosis of HTLV-1 infection or of HAM, duration of follow-up and death.

The clinical variables were use of walking aids, localisation and severity of pain, bladder and bowel function. Measurement of timed walk was initiated in 2001, as the seconds a patient takes to walk 10 m with or without a walking aid. Patients were categorised as using no aid (AID0), using one walking stick (AID1), using two walking sticks (AID2), using a frame (AID3) or being wheelchair-dependent (AID4). Pain was categorised by presence, localisation and severity, which was scored by the patient using a 10 cm long visual analogue scale. Bladder hyperactivity was recorded as urinary frequency and urgency, while urinary retention was recorded as the need for catheterisation. Bowel function was recorded as normal, mild (>3/week), moderate (1–3/week) and severe (<1/week) constipation. Data were collected on all symptomatic and potentially disease-modifying therapy given. Zidovudine and lamivudine were prescribed within a randomised controlled trial, which has been published,27 and ciclosporin was prescribed within an ongoing clinical trial during data collection for this study.

HTLV-1 viral loads (HTLV-1 DNA copies/100 peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs)), quantified by ‘in house’ real-time PCR using the Roche LightCycler (Roche, Mannheim, Germany), were assayed prospectively.28

Statistical analysis

Data were analysed in SPSS-14 (SPSS, Chicago, Illinois) using parametric (t test) and non-parametric tests (Mann–Whitney test and Wilcoxon Signed Ranks test) for continuous variables and χ2 (Pearson χ2 test/Fisher exact test) for categorical variables. The categorical variables were gender, ethnicity, perceived risk factor for HTLV-1 infection, first recalled symptom, use of walking aids, localisation of pain, bladder and bowel function, and death. The continuous variables were age at onset, age at diagnosis of HTLV-1 infection or of HAM, duration of disease and follow-up, timed walk, pain score and HTLV-1 viral load. Kaplan–Meier survival analysis was used for survival data. For the prediction of AID change, a logistic regression model was applied, using the following explanatory variables: age of onset, risk factors for HTLV-1 acquisition, HTLV-1 VL, rate of change timed walk, timed walk, absence/presence of pain and pain score at first visit. For the prediction of the deterioration of timed walk, a univariate general linear regression model was used, analysing the effects of the following covariates: age of onset, HTLV-1 VL, timed walk and pain score at first visit and fixed factors: gender, ethnicity, risk factor for HTLV-1 infection and absence/presence of pain. Forward and backward Wald was used for the best-fit model. Cox regression was used to create a predictive model for time-to-event data. Results were assumed to be statistically significant, and the null hypothesis was rejected if a p value of <0.05 was achieved.

Results

Of the 55 patients with HAM, 48 were included in the analysis. Seven patients were excluded, five because of insufficient data, one patient had polymyositis, and one had HIV-1 coinfection.

Table 1 gives an overview of the demographics, patients' age of onset and follow-up as well as a summary of disease-modifying and palliative medication prescribed at first visit. Patients were mostly female and of Afro-Caribbean origin, and reported mother-to-child transmission and/or unprotected sexual intercourse with a person from an endemic region as the most likely route of HTLV-1 acquisition. Four patients (8.3%) cited blood transfusion before 2002, when obligatory screening for HTLV-1/2 antibodies was implemented in the UK, as their sole risk.

Table 1

Demographics, follow-up and treatment of 48 patients with HTLV-1-associated myelopathy

The most common first symptom was unilateral leg weakness at a median age of 48 years. Five (10.4%) patients were diagnosed as having HTLV-1 infection prior to developing HAM, one of whom developed HAM during follow-up. In this subgroup, the median time from diagnosis of HTLV-1 infection to onset of disease was 1.2 years. The median follow-up was 3.8 years, resulting in 212 person-years (py) of follow-up. Oral prednisolone, zidovudine, lamivudine, methotrexate and ciclosporin were prescribed as disease-modifying drugs during follow-up.

Time to first use of a walking aid

At the baseline visit, 38 (79%) patients were walking compared with 32 (68%) patients at last clinic visit (p=0.25). At baseline 13 (27%) patients were walking unaided (AID0), 25 (52%) were using walking aids (AID1, 2 and 3), eight (17%) were wheelchair-dependent (AID4), and two (4%) were bed-bound. During follow-up, 19 (54%) patients needed additional aid: seven patients progressed to AID1, three to AID2, three to AID3 and six to AID4. The median times from onset of HAM to AID1, AID 2, AID 3 and AID4 were 11 (range 0.8–24.5, 95% CI 2.8 to 17.30), 11.2 (range 6.4–16.5, 95% CI 1.2 to 16), 11.3 (range 6.9–14, 95% CI 8.3 to 14) and 18 years (range 14–22.1, 95% CI 14 to 22).

At last visit, the mobility of two patients (4%) had improved: one could transfer from bed to wheelchair, and one needed one walking stick instead of two.

Progression in timed walks

Comparing baseline with last visit, the mean timed walk deteriorated in 29 (81%) by +4.25 s/10 m/year (−0.13 to 24.6, median 1.27) including four patients who became wheelchair-bound with a median deterioration rate of +17.1 s/10 m/year (+5.9 to +24.6). In seven patients (19%), timed walk improved by −35.5 s/10 m/year (−160 to −2.6, median −7.7), but these patients were followed up for only a median of 0.4 years (0.25 to 0.92), and the rate of improvement in timed walk has been assumed to continue at the same rate for the whole year and is therefore an overestimate. Timed walks deteriorated even in patients who walked without any need for further aid by a median of +1.98 s/10 m/year.

Four (11%) patients were categorised as long-term non-progressors: their median timed walk rate changed by only +0.2 s/10 m/year (−0.13 to +0.67) without needing any additional aid during a median follow-up of 4.3 years (2.7–6.8). Two (6%) patients were slow progressors: they needed one walking stick after a median of 11.5 years' (9.7 to 13.2) disease duration, and their median timed walk deteriorated by only +0.3 s/10 m/year (+0.24 to +0.33) during a median follow-up of 6.3 years (5.3 to 7.3). Three (6%) patients progressed rapidly and became wheelchair or bed-bound in less than 2 years from onset, one of whom died at the age of 40 years.

Timed walk, rate of progression and HTLV-1 VL were analysed by age of onset as presented in other publications.4 21 Patients with a younger age of onset (≤50 years) were more likely to use walking aids (p=0.005) and suffer from pain (p=0.03) at baseline than the older-onset group.

Four patients cited blood transfusion as their only risk for HTLV-1 acquisition, of which three patients recalled first symptoms at a young age (≤50 years). Although none of the patients progressed rapidly or died during follow-up, two patients needed more aid (a frame and a wheelchair), and the median rate of progression of timed walk was faster in these (+4.9 s/10 m/year (0.5 to 13.3), 95% CI 9.8 to +22) compared with non-transfused patients (+1.2 s/10 m/year (0.01 to 6.6), 95% CI +1.1 to +3, p=0.02).

Pain

Twenty-seven (63%) patients reported pain at first visit and 23 (53%) at last review (p=0.3). At both time points, more patients had permanent than intermittent pain (first: 11 (69%) vs five (31%); last: 13 (81%) vs three (19%)). Low-back pain alone was reported in 14 (52%), low-back and leg pain in seven (26%) and leg pain alone in five (19%). At last visit 8 (30%) patients had become pain free but 4 (25%) previously pain free patients reported pain.

The median pain score of the whole group did not differ significantly between first, 6 cm (2 to 10, 95% CI 4.9 to 7.1) and last visit, 5.5 cm (1.5 to 10, 95% CI 5.2 to 7.6, p=0.2). This, however, masks the considerable individual changes. In 10 patients, the pain score worsened significantly from a median of 2.5 cm (0 to 8, 95% CI 0.8 to 5.2) at first visit to 8 cm (4 to 10, 95% CI 5.7 to 8.8, p=0.05) at last visit. In 15 patients, pain improved significantly between the two time points (first: 7 cm (2 to 10), 95% CI 5 to 8; last: 0 cm (0 to 9.5), 95% CI 0.8 to 4.4).

Bladder and bowel function

There was no significant difference in the number of patients complaining of bladder problems at the two time points (first: 37/41 (90%) vs last 35/41 (85%), p=0.5), but significantly more patients were catheterising at last 20 (49%) compared with first visit 11 (27%) p=0.04.

Most patients suffered from bladder hyperactivity (32 (86%)), and urinary retention was observed in five (14%). Obstructive nephropathy was present at baseline in one patient and developed during follow-up in a second.

Twenty-five (63%) were constipated at first and 24 (60%) at last visit. This apparent lack of change masks considerable individual variation. In seven (18%) patients, constipation worsened between the first and last visit, while in 10 (25%), it improved, of whom seven (18%) became asymptomatic.

Mortality

During follow-up, five (10.6 %) patients died, giving a mortality of 2.4/100 py. Three patients were male, and the median age at time of death was 57 years (36 to 78). Four deaths were directly associated with HTLV-1 infection: one patient developed adult T cell leukaemia/lymphoma, one developed pneumonia with respiratory failure, and two had severe HAM with disseminated inflammation. The cause of death of one patient was unknown. Death occurred at a median of 9.7 years from onset (2.42 to 20.3) and 4.4 years of follow-up (1.34 to 10.7) (figure 1).

Figure 1

Kaplan–Meier survival analysis of all patients from onset of disease to last follow-up or death. Censored=patient reaching their last follow-up.

HTLV-1 viral load

The HTLV-1 viral load (VL) of the cohort remained essentially unchanged over time (first: median 14 (0.002 to 140), 95% CI 13 to 28 vs last: median 13 (0.01 to 70), 95% CI 13.3 to 24, p=0.6, figure 2). The median VL of the asymptomatic patient who developed HAM was high at baseline (9.8 (1.6 to 22.5) copies/100 PBMCs) and remained unchanged over time.

Figure 2

Mean HTLV-1 viral load (log copies/100 peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs)) of all patients by year of follow-up.

HTLV-1 VL was associated neither with a change in aid usage (p=0.8) nor with pain at baseline (p=0.7). Timed walk deterioration rate was not significantly associated with HTLV-1 VL at baseline (p=0.2). However, median HTLV-1 VL were higher in patients who were younger at onset and whose need for aid and timed walk increased over time (≤50 years: 11.2 (0.002 to 70), 95% CI 5.7 to 38; >50 years: 1.7 (1.2 to 2.4), 95% CI 0.8 to 2.7, p=0.09).

Prediction of deterioration of gait

In a logistic regression analysis investigating the association of an increase in AID usage with the in the methods section mentioned variables identified the rate of progression of timed walk/year (p=0.05, 95% CI 1 to 1.3) as the only significant parameter which predicted 69% of progression in aid correctly. A relationship between the rate of timed walk change/year and the in the methods section listed baseline measurements could not be established in a univariate general linear model.

Discussion

On the basis of ethnicity, our cohort data should be most comparable with data from the Caribbean and from Brazil.4 17 Similarities are the female predominance, route of HTLV-1 acquisition, onset before the age of 50, gait impairment as the most common first symptom and slow but continuous progression of disability as well as a high but stable HTLV-1 VL over time.

On average, patients are diagnosed earlier after the onset of HAM in the UK (mean 3.8, median 2 years) than in Martinique (mean 5.3, median 3 years). This might be due to patients' ability and/or choice to access healthcare earlier. In the UK, patients could walk unaided for longer (10 vs 6 years) and needed a wheelchair later (18 vs 21 years) than patients in Martinique. The difference in the time to first use of a walking aid could be due to an earlier diagnosis of HAM and/or more intense physiotherapy and symptomatic treatment of pain and spasticity in the UK.

Patients who were younger at onset had a higher baseline HTLV-1 VL and progressed more rapidly as assessed by the use of walking aids and timed walk. In addition, the few patients whose risk for acquiring HTLV-1 infection was a blood transfusion were also more likely to progress in their need for aid. The rate of deterioration of timed walk seemed to be weakly associated with higher HTLV-1 viral load at first visit, irrespective of an increase in aid usage in our cohort. These associations might be more significant in a larger cohort.

Timed walk rate is most meaningful for those patients who are not using any aid and are followed up for more than 1 year. We describe for the first time the expected rate of deterioration in a walking speed of 2 s/10 m/year in patients with HAM who do not require any change in walking aid. Thus, according to current disability scales, only 54% of our initially ambulant patients would have had a documented deterioration, whereas using timed walk, a further 20% of patients were seen to deteriorate during follow-up. These data, demonstrating an improvement in timed walk in patients who have only been attending the clinic for between 3 and 12 months, while suggesting that symptomatic management and physical therapy can have a significant impact on mobility in the short-term, should also caution that this may mask continuing progression of the underlying pathology. For the first time, we are describing patients with HAM whose rate of timed walk changed only ≤ 1 s/10 m/year from baseline during a follow-up time of ≥ 2 years as non-progressors if they did not need any walking aid and as slow-progressors if they needed only one additional aid. These definitions will help to compare HAM subgroups with those who progress continuously or rapidly. Furthermore, we have seen that the rate of deterioration in timed walk in patients who subsequently became wheelchair-dependent was much faster, suggesting that timed walks identify those patients most in need of therapeutic intervention.

HTLV-1 infection was associated with a 1.3-fold increased risk of death from all causes excluding ATLL in Japan.29 The relative mortality was 1.7 for HTLV-1 infected compared with uninfected subjects in Guinea-Bissau and was mortality associated with higher HTLV-1 viral loads but neither the cause of death nor the prevalence of ATLL is given.30 Twenty-five per cent of 123 patients with HAM from Martinique died within 20 years of disease onset.4 A report from the UK's Health Protection Agency documented a higher mortality associated with HTLV-1 infection in the UK in patients of Afro-Caribbean ethnicity and in those living far from centres looking after HTLV-1-positive patients (Tsui B, et al Mortality among individuals less than 60 years diagnosed as having HTLV-I in England and Wales: 1993–2003. 4 May 2005. Ref Type: Unpublished Work). In our population, 10.6% of the patients with HAM died within a mean of 9.7 years from the onset of HAM. The mortality in our cohort was 2.4/100 py follow-up compared with an age-adjusted mortality of 1/100 py in the general UK population. Therefore, a higher rate of all-cause non-neoplastic mortality is associated with HAM in the UK. Deaths in our cohort were more common in younger, more disabled patients and appeared to be more directly related to HTLV-1 infection, whereas in Martinique, deaths were mostly commonly due to complications of debilitating neurological disease.

We also present prospectively collected longitudinal data on HTLV-1 VL of patients with HAM. Neither the mean nor the median HTLV-1 viral load changed significantly over time, and more importantly the patient who developed HAM during follow-up had a high set point of HTLV-1 VL prior to onset of symptoms which fluctuated only insignificantly over time. However, we do not have enough data to prove that a significantly higher VL always precedes the development of HAM, although this is commonly assumed.

This study has the many limitations of a cohort study of a rare disease: small numbers, variable follow-up in some cases <1 year, no comparator arm and not controlled for treatment. The underlying deterioration of HAM resulting in a steady deterioration may obscure fluctuating improvements in patients followed up for longer, as only the final outcome is documented. Therefore, a potential transient improvement or stalling of the disease process might have been missed. However, careful description of a cohort essentially managed with only symptomatic therapies provides a rate of change in timed walk against which novel interventions can be judged. In conclusion, a 10 m timed walk, which is simple and accessible, provides a rapid and valuable additional clinical measure in patients with HAM, demonstrating the continuous progressive nature of this condition and a tool to identify patients who might benefit most from more targeted management.

References

  1. 1.
  2. 2.
  3. 3.
  4. 4.
  5. 5.
  6. 6.
  7. 7.
  8. 8.
  9. 9.
  10. 10.
  11. 11.
  12. 12.
  13. 13.
  14. 14.
  15. 15.
  16. 16.
  17. 17.
  18. 18.
  19. 19.
  20. 20.
  21. 21.
  22. 22.
  23. 23.
  24. 24.
  25. 25.
  26. 26.
  27. 27.
  28. 28.
  29. 29.
  30. 30.

Footnotes

  • Competing interests None.

  • Provenance and peer review Not commissioned; externally peer reviewed.

Request Permissions

If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.