Objective The aim of this study was to evaluate the efficacy and safety of high-dose taurine supplementation for prevention of stroke-like episodes of MELAS (mitochondrial myopathy, encephalopathy, lactic acidosis and stroke-like episodes), a rare genetic disorder caused by point mutations in the mitochondrial DNA that lead to a taurine modification defect at the first anticodon nucleotide of mitochondrial tRNALeu(UUR), resulting in failure to decode codons accurately.
Methods After the nationwide survey of MELAS, we conducted a multicentre, open-label, phase III trial in which 10 patients with recurrent stroke-like episodes received high-dose taurine (9 g or 12 g per day) for 52 weeks. The primary endpoint was the complete prevention of stroke-like episodes during the evaluation period. The taurine modification rate of mitochondrial tRNALeu(UUR) was measured before and after the trial.
Results The proportion of patients who reached the primary endpoint (100% responder rate) was 60% (95% CI 26.2% to 87.8%). The 50% responder rate, that is, the number of patients achieving a 50% or greater reduction in frequency of stroke-like episodes, was 80% (95% CI 44.4% to 97.5%). Taurine reduced the annual relapse rate of stroke-like episodes from 2.22 to 0.72 (P=0.001). Five patients showed a significant increase in the taurine modification of mitochondrial tRNALeu(UUR) from peripheral blood leukocytes (P<0.05). No severe adverse events were associated with taurine.
Conclusions The current study demonstrates that oral taurine supplementation can effectively reduce the recurrence of stroke-like episodes and increase taurine modification in mitochondrial tRNALeu(UUR) in MELAS.
Trial registration number UMIN000011908.
This is an open access article distributed in accordance with the Creative Commons Attribution Non Commercial (CC BY-NC 4.0) license, which permits others to distribute, remix, adapt, build upon this work non-commercially, and license their derivative works on different terms, provided the original work is properly cited and the use is non-commercial. See: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/
Statistics from Altmetric.com
Mitochondrial myopathy, encephalopathy, lactic acidosis and stroke-like episodes (MELAS) is a major clinical entity encompassing mitochondrial diseases resulting from mitochondrial dysfunction.1–3 Stroke-like episodes, the most critical symptom of MELAS, are characterised by an abrupt onset of cortical neurological deficits with typical MRI abnormalities not conforming to the distribution of main arteries.4 5 MELAS progresses over years with accumulation of neurological deficits resulting from recurrent stroke-like episodes, which dictate the prognosis of MELAS: 20.8% patients die within a median time of 7.3 years after diagnosis.6 From the onset of neurological deficits, the overall median survival time of patients with MELAS was estimated as 16.9 years.7
Among more than 50 causative mutations reported in the mitochondrial DNA,8 9 3243A>G and 3271T>C mutations in the mitochondrial tRNALeu(UUR) gene (MT-TL1) occur in 80%2 10 and 10%11 of patients with MELAS, respectively. The precise molecular mechanisms by which these point mutations lead to various clinical manifestations of MELAS remain to be elucidated.
In 1966, Francis Crick predicted certain chemical modifications at the first anticodon nucleotide of tRNAs because it interacts with the corresponding third codon nucleotide in mRNA through non-canonical Watson-Crick geometry, termed ‘wobble pairing’.12 Yasukawa et al found that taurine, a sulfur-containing β-amino acid, modifies the first anticodon nucleotide in normal human mitochondrial tRNALeu(UUR).13 Surprisingly, the taurine modification was absent in mitochondrial tRNALeu(UUR) of cells derived from patients with MELAS harbouring the 3243A>G or 3271T>C mutation.14 15 Because the defect in taurine modification in mutant mitochondrial tRNALeu(UUR) causes a failure in deciphering the cognate codon,15 these findings raised an intriguing possibility that MELAS results from mitochondrial dysfunction due to defective mitochondrial gene translation. More recently, knockout of the taurine modification enzyme proved impairment of mitochondrial translation and respiratory activity.16
From the first-ever proposal by Yasukawa et al 13, a novel disease concept termed tRNA modification disorders, encompassing over 18 diseases, including amyotrophic lateral sclerosis, type 2 diabetes and several genetic disorders, has recently emerged.17 To date, no therapeutic intervention has yet succeeded in alleviating impaired tRNA modifications observed in these disorders.17 We postulated that high-dose taurine supplementation would restore the taurine modification defect in mutant mitochondrial tRNALeu(UUR) and ameliorate mitochondrial dysfunction and clinical manifestations in patients with MELAS. Indeed, we previously showed that addition of taurine to the culture media at the final concentration of 0.3 mM alleviated the decreases in VO2 and mitochondrial membrane potential in patient-derived pathogenic cells harbouring the 3243A>G mutation.18 In a preliminary study, high-dose oral administration of 12 g taurine elevated the plasma concentration above 0.3 mM and completely prevented stroke-like episodes in two patients with MELAS for more than 9 years.18
Following a nationwide survey of MELAS across Japan, we conducted a multicentre, open-label, phase III trial to evaluate the efficacy and safety of high-dose taurine supplementation for prevention of stroke-like episodes. We further investigated the molecular effect of taurine supplementation by determining taurine modification in mitochondrial tRNALeu(UUR) from peripheral blood leucocytes of participants in the trial.
To enrol participants in this clinical trial, we performed a nationwide survey of patients with MELAS across Japan (figure 1, online supplementary figure S1–4). We conducted a primary screening by sending questionnaires to determine the number of patients with MELAS in 911 clinical departments. The design of the trial protocol and enrolment of participants were based on the information obtained with the secondary and tertiary screenings.
Eligible patients were those diagnosed with MELAS according to the Japanese diagnostic criteria for MELAS,6 which were based on the previous criteria by Hirano et al 19 and Hirano and Pavlakis,20 in agreement with the MELAS study committee in Japan.
Candidates were screened by genetic testing to identify patients harbouring 3243A>G, 3271T>G, 3244G>A, 3258T>C or 3291T>C mutations proven to cause the taurine modification defect in mitochondrial tRNALeu(UUR).21 Additional eligibility criteria included prior continuous administration of other therapies,22 such as coenzyme Q10,23 antiepileptics and nitric oxide donors including L-arginine.24 Detailed inclusion and exclusion criteria are presented in UMIN clinical trial database (http://www.umin.ac.jp; UMIN000011908).
The dose of orally administered taurine was determined based on the participant’s body weight categories, 12 g for 40 kg or more, 9 g for 25–39 kg, 6 g for 15–24 kg and 3 g for less than 15 kg, so as to reach the effective plasma concentration of taurine, 0.3 mM, which improves mitochondrial dysfunction in our previous study.18
We defined stroke-like episodes of MELAS in the inclusion criteria as focal neurological deficits with abrupt onset, including (1) hemiparesis or monoparesis, (2) cortical sensory deficit (extinction), (3) cortical visual deficit, (4) aphasia, (5) apraxia and (6) agnosia. At the time of registration, brain MRI was not mandatory in order to avoid underestimation of the frequency of stroke-like episodes during the pretrial period. Based on the data from the nationwide survey, we selected participants who had frequent recurrence of stroke-like episodes; more than twice within the last 78 weeks and at least once within the last 52 weeks before the date of enrolment.
Taurine was administered for 52 weeks of the trial period and the first 8 weeks after the taurine administration were not included in the evaluation period (figure 2). Stroke-like episodes observed during the evaluation period were precisely defined as abrupt-onset focal neurological deficits confirmed by brain MRI abnormalities.
Taisho Pharmaceutical (Tokyo, Japan) provided good manufacturing practice-grade taurine. This trial was conducted in accordance with the Good Clinical Practice guidelines25 and approved by Pharmaceuticals and Medical Devices Agency on 13 September 2013. Each institutional review board (IRB) of individual 10 clinical institutions participating in this trial approved all trial procedures, and all patients provided written informed consent before the start of the trial. After participants’ registration, this trial was stated from 3 October 2013.
Efficacy and safety assessment
The primary endpoint was the 100% responder rate, defined as the percentage of patients with no stroke-like episodes during the trial period. The secondary endpoints included the following: (1) the 50% responder rate defined as the percentage of patients achieving 50% or greater reduction in frequency of stroke-like episodes during the trial period; (2) the number of attacks with focal neurological deficits with or without brain MRI abnormalities; (3) the levels of lactate, pyruvate and taurine in blood and cerebrospinal fluid (CSF); (4) the number of times high-intensity lesions were confirmed with brain MRI in patients suffering from headache, nausea, vomiting, seizure or impaired consciousness; (5) the frequency of intravenous treatment with L-arginine24 before or after taurine administration, and (6) the disease severity index in accordance with the Japanese Mitochondrial Disease Rating Scale,6 which was modified from the European Neuromuscular Conference mitochondrial disease scale.26
Safety was assessed by analysing adverse events between the date of enrolment and the end of the trial. Assessment included any changes in physical examination, Mini Mental State Examination, laboratory tests and echocardiography. Patients and guardians were informed on precautionary measures and warning signs.
Analysis of taurine modification of mitochondrial tRNALeu(UUR)
As a first-in-human analysis, we measured the rate of taurine modification of mitochondrial tRNALeu(UUR) in peripheral blood leucocytes using the primer extension method.21 Briefly, the specific reverse primer, ACCTCTGACTGTAAAG, which corresponds to the 3′-adjacent site of the anticodon in mitochondrial tRNALeu(UUR) was 5′-labelled with [γ-32P]ATP using T4 polynucleokinase (T4 PNK; NEB, Boston, Massachusetts, USA). Total RNA isolated from peripheral blood leucocytes was reverse-transcribed with the labelled primer using a Moloney mouse leukaemia virus (M-MuLV) reverse transcriptase (Thermo Fisher Scientific, Waltham, Massachusetts, USA) with dATP, dTTP and ddGTP. The reaction mixture was electrophoresed in a 15% polyacrylamide gel containing 7 M urea. The 20 bp and 21 bp bands corresponding to the labelled partial cDNA products with (Tau (+)) or without (Tau (−)) taurine modification of the first anticodons, respectively, were visualised. The taurine modification rate (%) was calculated based on the densitometric intensities of the 20 bp and 21 bp bands using the following formula: intensityTau (+)/(intensityTau (+)+intensityTau (−))×100. Details are described in the online supplementary file.
The 100% and 50% responder rates and 95% Pearson-Clopper CIs were estimated. For other endpoints, one-sample t-test or Wilcoxon signed-rank test was used to compare pre-treatment and post-treatment values. Two-sided P values of <0.05 were considered statistically significant for all analyses. For this trial, the intent-to-treat population was defined as all subjects enrolled in the trial who received at least one dose of taurine; all patients were analysed for primary and secondary endpoints. A sample size of 10 subjects was required to test the null hypothesis that the true 100% responder rate was ≤5% with the alternative hypothesis that the true 100% responder rate was ≥50%, with more than 90% power and an alpha level of 0.05. All analyses were performed using SAS statistical software (V.9.3; SAS Institute, Cary, North Carolina, USA).
A total of 291 patients with MELAS were identified by the nationwide MELAS survey from January to May 2013 (figure 1, online supplementary figure S1, 2) from 911 clinical departments across Japan. Since the population of Japan was approximately 126 million in 2013, the prevalence of MELAS was estimated as at least 0.22 per 100 000 population. Eighty-five patients (29.2%) had more than two stroke-like episodes within the last 2 years. Secondary screening (online supplementary figure S3) identified 28 patients having frequent stroke-like episodes without severe clinical complications.
Based on the tertiary screening (online supplementary figure S4), 10 patients from 10 departments who met the inclusion criteria were enrolled in the study (figures 1 and 2). Baseline characteristics of the patients are presented in table 1. The mean age of participants was 29.1 years (range, 14–46 years). The patients received 9 g or 12 g taurine per day for 52 weeks. Nine patients harboured the 3243A>G mutation and one had the 3271T>C mutation in the mitochondrial DNA. The degree of heteroplasmy, that is, the percentage of mutant mitochondrial DNA, ranged from 21.5% to 65.8% in peripheral blood leucocytes. The number of stroke-like episodes within the 78 weeks before trial enrolment ranged between 2 and 6, regardless of prior continuous administration of other drugs, including CoQ10, L-arginine and dichloroacetic acid (figure 3). Among a total of 33 stroke-like episodes experienced by patients before taurine supplementation, brain MRI examination was performed in only 20 episodes (online supplementary table S1).
All 10 patients experienced a decrease in frequency of stroke-like episodes with taurine supplementation therapy (table 1, figure 3). Six patients had no stroke-like episodes confirmed by the absence of MRI abnormalities during the evaluation period (patients 1, 3, 5, 6, 7 and 9; table 1, figure 3). Thus, the primary outcome of the trial, the 100% responder rate was 60.0% (95% CI 26.2% to 87.8%), and the lower limit of 95% CI was higher than the 100% responder rate of 5% under the null hypothesis.
During the 52 weeks of trial period, the frequency of stroke-like episodes was decreased more than 50% in eight patients treated with taurine (patients 1, 3, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9 and 10; table 1, figure 3) compared with those not treated with taurine; thus, the 50% responder rate was 80% (95% CI 44.4% to 97.5%). Additionally, the number of focal neurological deficits significantly decreased from 33 during the pretrial period to 8 during the evaluation period (online supplementary table S1, 2). Thus, oral taurine supplementation significantly reduced the annual relapse rate of focal neurological deficits from 2.22±0.73 to 0.72±0.62 (P=0.001, table 2). A single patient (patient 5) experienced a non-focal neurological deficit, headache and nausea, concomitantly with a high-intensity lesion in the brain MRI.
Taurine supplementation therapy significantly increased the levels of taurine in blood (945.67±406.18 vs 57.57±20.29 nmol/mL, P=0.0001) and CSF (42.11±13.77 vs 11.24±2.88 nmol/mL, P=0.0007; table 2). No significant changes were observed in other efficacy endpoints except taurine concentrations in the blood and CSF (table 2).
We evaluated the rate of taurine modification in mitochondrial tRNALeu(UUR) from peripheral blood leucocytes in nine patients as a first-in-human analysis (figure 4). The rate of taurine modification of mitochondrial tRNALeu(UUR) was significantly increased in five patients (P<0.05).
None of the patients discontinued treatment with taurine supplementation, although 84 adverse events occurred in all 10 patients over 52 weeks of treatment (table 3). Six patients experienced adverse events associated with taurine supplementation. Two severe adverse events were reported in two patients: serum creatine kinase elevation and acute gastroenteritis. However, these were not considered to be due to taurine supplementation.
The present clinical trial demonstrated that oral supplementation with high-dose taurine was effective in preventing stroke-like episodes, as evidenced by the high 100% responder rate of 60% (95% CI 26.2% to 87.8%). The lower limit of 95% CI was higher than the true 100% responder rate of 5% under the null hypothesis. Furthermore, the 50% responder rate reached 80%, and the annual relapse rate of stroke-like episodes significantly decreased with concomitant increases in blood and CSF taurine levels. Adverse events associated with taurine were observed among the participants, but no serious adverse events associated with taurine supplementation were reported.
Growing evidence suggest that dysfunction in post-transcriptional tRNA modifications can lead to various pathological conditions, termed as tRNA modification disorders.17 Critically, the loss of modification in the first anticodon nucleotide of mitochondrial tRNALeu(UUR) in MELAS was expected to directly inhibit its pairing to the cognate third codon nucleotide in mRNA as predicted by Crick.12 In this study, we showed that the high-dose taurine supplementation was able to ameliorate taurine modification defect in mitochondrial tRNALeu(UUR) in peripheral blood leucocytes in vivo, which supported a therapeutic rationale of the taurine supplementation. High-dose taurine could improve the taurine modification of the mitochondrial tRNALeu(UUR) by the first anticodon modification enzyme, mitochondrial translation optimisation 1 (MTO1).16 In addition, taurine could alleviate impaired energy metabolism through increase of ATP production in the pathogenesis leading to MELAS.27
Several clinical trials have been conducted for the treatment of MELAS22; however, thus far, no therapeutic rationale based on molecular mechanisms of this disease has been provided. Taurine is a physiological amino acid that accounts for 0.1% of the human body weight.28 It is derived mostly from food and, to a lesser extent, endogenously synthesised from cysteine and methionine. Thus, establishing a safe taurine supplementation therapy is a significant progress in the treatment of this devastating, rare genetic disorder.
Limitations of this study include the lack of a double-blind, placebo-control group of taurine supplementation due to the small number of participants fulfilling the inclusion criteria. The nationwide survey estimated the Japanese prevalence of MELAS as at least 0.22 per 100 000 population, which is consistent with the previous Japanese study.6 In addition, short life expectancy and poor prognosis described in natural history studies6 7 29 practically confined the number of participants as well as ethically allowed the continuation of other therapies prior to taurine supplementation. Indeed, 9 of 10 participants were priorly administered L-arginine, which was reported to decrease the frequency of stroke-like episodes in a clinical study.24 However, even in these patients, the frequency of stroke-like episodes was remarkably decreased with taurine supplementation. Further clinical studies are required to determine the synergy effect of taurine and L-arginine for prevention of stroke-like episodes in MELAS.
In conclusion, in this open-label, phase III trial, oral high-dose taurine supplementation was effective and safe for the prevention of stroke-like episodes in patients with MELAS by ameliorating the modification defect in the first anticodon nucleotide of mitochondrial tRNALeu(UUR).
We are grateful to K Tanda, F Uemura, M Ogawa, Y Shimada, T Ohtsuki, T Irinaga, K Sakai and M Tsuboi (Department of Neurology, Kawasaki Medical School) for their technical assistance.
Contributors YO, HH, AH, YK, YG and YS conceptualised and designed the study, recruited patients, contributed data, performed statistical analysis, interpreted the results, and drafted and edited the manuscript. SN, NK, HO, YF, TM and SO analysed mitochondrial genotype, heteroplasmy and taurine modification. KN01 Study Members collected data for this study. All authors approved the submission.
Funding This study was funded by Research on Rare and Intractable Diseases, Health and Labour Sciences Research Grants from the Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare of Japan (H24-Nanchitou(Nan)-Ippan-068) and by Japan Agency for Medical Research and Development (AMED) under grant numbers JP15ek0109093h0001, JP16ek0109093h0002 and JP17ek0109093h0003.
Disclaimer The sponsors played no role in the study design; the collection, analysis and the interpretation of data; the writing of the report; or the decision to submit the article for publication.
Competing interests YS reports the following research grants: Intramural Neurological and Psychiatric Disorders from the National Center of Neurology and Psychiatry (26-8), Grants-in-Aid for Scientific Research from the Japan Society for the Promotion of Science (C-24591281, C-26461285) and by research project grants from Kawasaki Medical School (23-T1, 26-T1).
Patient consent Obtained.
Ethics approval Each institutional review board (IRB) of individual 10 clinical institutions participating in this trial approved all trial procedures.
Provenance and peer review Not commissioned; externally peer reviewed.
Collaborators KN01 Study Group includes the following people: H Onoue, K Kaida (National Defense Medical College Hospital, Tokyo, Japan), K Sato, T Uchiyama (Seirei Hamamatsu General Hospital, Shizuoka, Japan), A Ueda, T Mutoh (Fujita Health University School Hospital, Aichi, Japan), M Nakamura (National Hospital Organization Kyoto Medical Center, Kyoto, Japan), K Nishida, I Funakawa (National Hospital Organization Hyogo-Chuo National Hospital, Hyogo, Japan), A Ogawa (Chikushi Hospital, Fukuoka University, Fukuoka, Japan), R Nakata, H Shiraishi, A Tsujino (Nagasaki University Hospital, Nagasaki, Japan), T Takahashi and M Matsumoto (Hiroshima University Hospital, Hiroshima, Japan).
If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.