Reference/date | No of participants | Location | Study recruitment dates | Overall SMR |
Hoehn17 1967 | 241* | USA | 1949–64 | 2.9 |
Nobrega18 1969 | 203 | USA | 1935–66 | 1.6 |
Sweet19 1975 | 100† | USA | 1968 | 1.9 |
Barbeau20 1976 | 80† | Canada | 1968 | 2.4 |
Diamond1 1976 | 1087 | USA | 1968–69 | 1.0 |
Zumstein21 1976 | 1155† | NA | 1969–71 | 1.0 |
Marttila22 1977 | 349† | Finland | 1969–75 | 1.9 |
Joseph23 1978 | 1625† | USA | 1969 | 1.3 |
Diamond,24 1979 | 327† | USA | 1972 | 1.4 |
Rinne25 1980 | 349† | Finland | 1969 | 1.6 |
Curtis26 1984 | 176† | UK | 1969–72 | 2.6 |
Rajput27 1984 | 138/276‡ | USA | 1967–79 | 1.6 |
Cedarbaum28 1987 | 100† | USA | 1968 | 1.9 |
Diamond29 1989 | 359 | USA | 1968–70 | 2.1 |
Ebmeier30 1990 | 243 | UK | 1984 | 2.3 |
Kuroda31 1992 | 438 | Japan | 1978 | 2.5 |
Ben-Shlomo 7 1995 | 220/421‡ | UK | 1970–72 | 2.6 |
Wermuth32 1995 | 458 | Denmark | 1973–91 | 1.9 |
Bennett33 1996 | 159 | USA | 1982–84 | 2.0 |
Morens34 1996 | 8006§ | USA | 1965 | 2.5 |
Tison12 1996 | 24/2768¶ | France | 1988 | 3.4 |
Louis35 1997 | 154/1254‡ ** | USA | 1988 | 2.7 |
Schrag6 1998 | 132†† | UK | 1981–98 | 2.1 |
Hely36 1999 | 149 | Australia | 1984–87 | 1.6 |
Berger13 2000 | 139/11694‡‡ | Europe | 1987–92 | 2.3 |
Donnan37 2000 | 97/902† | UK | 1989–95 | 1.8 |
Morgante14 2000 | 59/118 | Italy | 1987 | 2.3 |
Guttman38 2001 | 15304/30608‡ §§ | Canada | 1993–94 | 2.5 |
Lees4 2001 | 782† | UK | 1985–90 | 1.8 |
Montastruc39 2001 | 58† | France | 1982–89 | 1.2 |
Parashos40 2002 | 89/89‡ | USA | 1979–88 | 2.2 |
Elbaz41 2003 | 196/185‡ | USA | 1976–95 | 1.6 |
Fall42 2003 | 170/510‡ | Sweden | 1989 | 1.6¶¶ |
Herlofson15 2004 | 245 | Norway | 1993 | 1.5*** |
Hughes43 2004 | 90/50‡ | UK | 1985–86 | 1.6 |
de Lau44 2005 | 166/6803‡‡ | Netherlands | 1990–93 | 1.8 |
Marras5 2005 | 800† | USA and Canada (DATATOP) | 1987–88 | 1.0 |
D’Amelio16 2006 | 58/116‡ | Italy | 1987 | 1.8 |
Chen45 2006 | 288/51300§ ‡‡ | USA | 1986–2000 | 1.6 |
NA, not available; PD, Parkinson’s disease.
*672 patients with primary parkinsonism with a mean age of 55.3 years, but only 241 were used for mortality calculations.
†Data from a drug clinical trial.
‡Case control study number of cases/number of controls.
§Men only.
¶Population based cohort (n = 2792) with 16 deaths in patients with PD and 605 non-PD.
**Non-demented patients with PD compared with controls.
††132 of 139 young onset PD cases (onset aged 21–39 years) had mortality data.
‡‡Cohort study number of cases/total cohort.
§§This study used parkinsonism from records of physician diagnoses or PD drugs as the outcome of interest.
¶¶Cumulative mortality incidence ratio; Cox proportional hazards ratio was 2.4.
***SMR was 1.5 in all 245 identified PD cases, but the SMR was 1.35 in definite PD, 1.42 in definite and probable PD, and 1.99 in possible PD.