Letter to the editor

Spline computation of scalp current density and coherence: a reply to Perrin

Surface Laplacian (SL) methods offer advantages in spectral analysis owing to the well-known implications of volume conduction. Although recognition of the superiority of SL over reference-dependent measures is widespread, well-reasoned cautions have precluded their universal adoption. Notably, the expected selectivity of SL for superficial rather than deep generators has relegated SL to the role of an add-on to conventional analyses, rather than as an independent area of inquiry, despite empirical findings supporting the consistency and replicability of physiological effects of interest. It has also been reasoned that the contrast-enhancing effects of SL necessarily make it insensitive to broadly distributed generators, including those suspected for oscillatory rhythms such as EEG alpha. These concerns are further exacerbated for phase-sensitive measures (e.g., phase-locking, coherence), where key features of physiological generators have yet to be evaluated. While the neuronal generators of empirically-derived EEG measures cannot be precisely known due to the inverse problem, simple dipole generator configurations can be simulated using a 4-sphere head model and linearly combined. We simulated subdural and deep generators and distributed dipole layers using sine and cosine waveforms, quantified at 67-scalp sites corresponding to those used in previous research. Reference-dependent (nose, average, mastoids reference) EEG and corresponding SL topographies were used to probe signal fidelity in the topography of the measured amplitude spectra, phase and coherence of sinusoidal stimuli at and between “active” recording sites. SL consistently outperformed the conventional EEG measures, indicating that continued reluctance by the research community is unfounded.

(1) To investigate the neural synchrony hypothesis by examining if there was more synchrony for upright than inverted Mooney faces, replicating a previous study; (2) to investigate whether inverted stimuli evoke neural synchrony by comparing them to a new scrambled control condition, less likely to produce face perception.

Multichannel EEG was recorded via nose reference while participants viewed upright, inverted, and scrambled Mooney face stimuli. Gamma-range spectral power and inter-electrode phase synchrony were calculated via a wavelet-based method for upright stimuli perceived as faces and inverted/scrambled stimuli perceived as non-faces.

When the frequency of interest was selected from the upright condition exhibiting maximal spectral power responses (as in the previous study) greater phase synchrony was found in the upright than inverted/scrambled conditions. However, substantial synchrony was present in all conditions, suggesting that choosing the frequency of interest from the upright condition only may have been biased. In addition, artifacts related to nose reference contamination by micro-saccades were found to be differentially present across experimental conditions in the raw EEG. When frequency of interest was selected instead from each experimental condition and the data were transformed to a laplacian ‘reference free’ derivation, the between-condition phase synchrony differences disappeared. Spectral power differences were robust to the change in reference, but not the combined changes in reference and frequency selection criteria.

Synchrony differences between face/non-face perceptions depend upon frequency selection and recording reference. Optimal selection of these parameters abolishes differential synchrony between conditions.

Neural synchrony is present not just for face percepts for upright stimuli, but also for non-face percepts achieved for inverted/scrambled Mooney stimuli.

Objective: In the present study the Stroop effect is analyzed by means of EEG coherence analysis in addition to traditional analysis of behavioral data (reaction time) and ERP analysis. Data from 10 normal subjects are examined.

Methods: In particular, a special dynamic approach for a continuous coherence estimation is applied to investigate the procedural evolution of functional cortical relationships during the Stroop task.

Results: The frequency band of 13–20 Hz is found to be sensitive to the discrimination between the congruent and the incongruent task conditions on the basis of instantaneous coherence analysis. The magnitude of coherence values within the time interval of late potentials and the maximal coherence values are used to assess the strength of interaction between distinct areas of the cortex. Higher coherences are observed within the left frontal and left parietal areas, as well as between them for the incongruent situation in comparison with the congruent situation. Furthermore, the time-points of maximal coherence allows a procedural discrimination between both situations. The peak synchrony described by the time-points of maximal coherence correlates strongly with the reaction times mainly within the frontal area and between fronto-parietal areas in the incongruent case, whereas this correlation is restricted to the right hemisphere in the congruent case.

To study hemispheric lateralization of cortical potentials associated with motoric and non-motoric function, cortical activity was recorded accompanying either finger extension or saccadic eye movements in a contingent negative variation (CNV) paradigm. Subjects viewed computer-generated pacing stimuli, presented in the left visual hemi-field, and were instructed to either initiate or inhibit a motor response following an imperative signal. Motoric lateralization was assessed by means of the lateralized readiness potential (LRP). In addition, a measure complementary to the LRP was introduced to investigate non-motoric lateralization (NML). Contralateral inter-hemispheric lateralization was evident in the LRP preceding finger movement, but was absent prior to eye movements. However, pre-saccadic cortical response profiles did exhibit a right hemispheric, non-motoric lateralization (NML) during stimulus presentation. Comparable non-motoric lateralization was found for finger extension. Results of the present study suggest that non-motoric lateralization may be a contributing factor to the frequently reported inter-hemispheric asymmetry preceding self-initiated saccadic eye movements. Results of the present study also suggest that the latter may be related to a covert shift of visuospatial attention toward the saccadic target. Associated shifts of attention are suppressed in a CNV paradigm, where attentional focus is primarily on the CNV stimulus during the pre-saccade period.

EEG coherence can be used to evaluate the functionality of cortical connections and to get information about the synchronization of the regional cortical activity. We studied EEG coherence in patients affected by clinically probable Alzheimer's disease (AD) in order to quantify the modifications in the cortico-cortical or cortico-subcortical connections. The EEGs were recorded in 10 AD patients (with mild or moderate degrees of dementia) and in 10 normal age-matched subjects, at rest and eye-closed, from 16 electrodes with linked-ears reference. Spectral parameters and coherence were calculated by a multichannel autoregressive model using 50 artifact-free epochs, 1 s duration each. Alpha coherence was significantly decreased in 6 patients, the decrease being more accentuated in the area near the electrode taken into account; a significant delta coherence increase was found in a few patients between frontal and posterior regions. The AD group showed a significant decrease of alpha band coherence, in particular in temporo-parieto-occipital areas, more evident in patients with a more severe cognitive impairment. These abnormalities could reflect two different pathophysiological changes: the alpha coherence decrease could be related to alterations in cortico-cortical connections, whereas the delta coherence increase could be related to the lack of influence of subcortical cholinergic structures on cortical electrical activity.