ArticlesDiagnostic precision of PET imaging and functional MRI in disorders of consciousness: a clinical validation study
Introduction
Many studies have been done on the differential diagnosis of disorders of consciousness.1 The term covers several pathological states, characterised by diminished consciousness and responsiveness. Among these, patients with unresponsive wakefulness syndrome, also known as a vegetative state,1, 2 retain arousal but show no behavioural signs of awareness.3, 4 Patients in a minimally conscious state show fluctuating awareness, and can respond appropriately to some stimuli.5 By convention, emergence from minimally conscious state arises when the patient regains a capacity for functional communication or object use.5 Because these states occupy a border zone between awareness and unconsciousness, the distinction between them has important ethical and therapeutic implications.3 For example, patients in minimally conscious states are more likely to have pain or suffer, and might benefit from analgesic treatment or other interventions aimed to improve quality of life.6, 7 Patients in a minimally conscious state are also more likely to recover higher levels of consciousness than are patients with unresponsive wakefulness syndrome.3, 8 Several countries have established the legal right of physicians to withdraw artificial life support from patients with unresponsive wakefulness syndrome9, 10, 11 but not from patients in a minimally conscious state.12
The detection of unambiguous signs of consciousness in severely brain-damaged patients is challenging. The frequency of misdiagnoses of patients with unresponsive wakefulness syndrome by clinical consensus methods is up to 40%.13, 14, 15 This error rate can be attenuated by the use of standardised scoring systems, such as the Coma Recovery Scale–Revised (CRS–R).16, 17, 18 However, misdiagnosis can still arise even with rigorous behavioural testing.19 Neuroimaging methods are being developed to complement the bedside examinations to investigate whether a patient has cerebral activity compatible with consciousness. These tests can assess spontaneous brain activity in the so-called resting brain, or specific responses to mental tasks. For example, findings of recent neuroimaging studies19, 20, 21 show that some patients diagnosed with unresponsive wakefulness syndrome probably can modulate their thoughts voluntarily, which suggests at least minimal awareness. The existence of locked-in syndrome22, 23, 24 proves that even behaviourally unresponsive patients can be conscious. This knowledge of a patient otherwise perceived as unconscious fundamentally alters his or her ethical, legal, and possibly social and therapeutic standing.
Consciousness is supported by internally and externally related awareness networks encompassing the frontoparietal associative cortices, cingulate gyrus, precuneus, and thalamus.24, 25, 26, 27, 28 Neural activity in these areas can be examined by 18F-fluorodeoxyglucose (FDG) PET, which allows visualisation of glucose metabolism at a whole brain level. Generally, the rate of cerebral energy turnover is proportional to the rate of synaptic firing. Therefore, lowered glucose metabolic rates suggest dysfunctional or dormant brain areas.29 Specific metabolic decreases of the frontoparietal associative cortices are seen in patients with unresponsive wakefulness syndrome and those in a minimally conscious state. Patients in a minimally conscious state maintain partial metabolism in the frontoparietal networks, whereas patients with unresponsive wakefulness syndrome show a broad bilateral frontoparietal dysfunction.24, 30, 31, 32 Similar findings of extensive frontoparietal hypometabolism are seen in deep sleep33 and general anaesthesia,27 suggesting that this pattern is associated with unawareness.
Activity in neuronal populations also triggers fluctuations in capillary deoxyhaemoglobin concentrations. Such increases can be seen with functional MRI (fMRI), and form the basis of maps of the functional architecture of brain activity.34 When asked to do mental tasks, such as motor or visuospatial imagery tasks, healthy patients generate reproducible and specific patterns of brain activation.35 Some patients with unresponsive wakefulness syndrome or those in a minimally conscious state can do similar mental tasks on request.19, 20, 21 Assuming that such brain activations constitute mental parallels of outward communication, fMRI testing might enable detection of consciousness in cases in which severe paralysis or spasticity makes regular communication impossible.
On the basis of these studies, FDG PET and fMRI might, in theory, distinguish patients in a minimally conscious state from those with unresponsive wakefulness syndrome. Because patients in a minimally conscious state, compared with patients with unresponsive wakefulness syndrome, have better outcomes, neuroimaging tests could also provide prognostic predictions. However, the diagnostic utility of these tests needs validation in clinical practice.
We aimed to test the hypothesis that neuroimaging with 18F-FDG PET at rest and fMRI during mental tasks can complement bedside clinical detection of consciousness and prediction of recovery. Inclusion of patients with locked-in syndrome (ie, a brain-damaged yet conscious control group)24 allows internal validity to be controlled by verifying the ability of the tests to detect awareness in fully conscious but physically incapacitated patients.
Section snippets
Study design and participants
For this clinical validation study, we included patients referred to the University Hospital of Liège, Belgium, from clinical centres across Europe between January, 2008, and June, 2012, who were diagnosed with CRS–R as having unresponsive wakefulness syndrome, having locked-in syndrome, or being in a minimally conscious state. These patients were assessed with at least one neuroimaging-based examination. The study was approved by the Ethics Committee of the University Hospital of Liège, and
Results
130 people were eligible for the study but four were excluded because neuropsychologists could not reach a consensus diagnosis. The final patient population comprised 126 patients (mean age 41, SD 18 years, 75 men). At time of referral, 81 patients had been diagnosed as being in a minimally conscious state, 41 with unresponsive wakefulness syndrome, and four with locked-in syndrome (table 1).
All 126 patients who received a clinical consensus diagnosis before admission were included irrespective
Discussion
As previously reported,13 we noted the clinical consensus diagnosis was imprecise. Even when we discounted the many unclear diagnoses, the clinical consensus diagnosis failed to correctly identify responsiveness in 33% of patients diagnosed as being in a minimally conscious state with CRS–R. This finding emphasises the need for standardised behavioural scoring systems in treatment facilities.
We recorded strong associations between results of clinical and functional neuroimaging tests. 18F-FDG
References (51)
- et al.
Coma and consciousness: paradigms (re)framed by neuroimaging
Neuroimage
(2012) - et al.
The vegetative and minimally conscious states: diagnosis, prognosis and treatment
Neurol Clin
(2011) - et al.
Perception of pain in the minimally conscious state with PET activation: an observational study
Lancet Neurol
(2008) - et al.
The JFK Coma Recovery Scale-Revised: measurement characteristics and diagnostic utility
Arch Phys Med Rehabil
(2004) - et al.
Bedside detection of awareness in the vegetative state: a cohort study
Lancet
(2011) - et al.
Brain function in coma, vegetative state, and related disorders
Lancet Neurol
(2004) - et al.
Consciousness supporting networks
Curr Opin Neurobiol
(2013) - et al.
When thoughts become action: an fMRI paradigm to study volitional brain activity in non-communicative brain injured patients
Neuroimage
(2007) - et al.
Assessment scales for disorders of consciousness: evidence-based recommendations for clinical practice and research
Arch Phys Med Rehabil
(2010) - et al.
Measurements of consciousness in the vegetative state
Lancet
(2011)
Behavioral assessment in patients with disorders of consciousness: gold standard or fool's gold?
Prog Brain Res
Rationale and design of the prospective German registry of outcome in patients with severe disorders of consciousness after acute brain injury
Arch Phys Med Rehabil
Unresponsive wakefulness syndrome: a new name for the vegetative state or apallic syndrome
BMC Med
Medical aspects of the persistent vegetative state (1). The Multi-Society Task Force on PVS
N Engl J Med
The minimally conscious state: definition and diagnostic criteria
Neurology
A sensitive scale to assess nociceptive pain in patients with disorders of consciousness
J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry
Long-term outcomes of chronic minimally conscious and vegetative states
Neurology
Latest legal and social developments in the euthanasia debate: bad moral consciences and political unrest
Med Law
The Terri Schiavo case: legal, ethical, and medical perspectives
Ann Intern Med
Withdrawing life support from patients in a persistent vegetative state: the law in the Netherlands
Eur J Health Law
Withdrawal of life-sustaining treatment from a patient in a minimally conscious state
J Law Med
Diagnostic accuracy of the vegetative and minimally conscious state: clinical consensus versus standardized neurobehavioral assessment
BMC Neurol
Misdiagnosis of the vegetative state: retrospective study in a rehabilitation unit
BMJ
Misdiagnosing the persistent vegetative state. Misdiagnosis certainly occurs
BMJ
A French validation study of the Coma Recovery Scale-R (CRS-R)
Brain Injury [BI]
Cited by (369)
Neuroimaging in Disorders of Consciousness and Recovery
2024, Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation Clinics of North AmericaTowards modern post-coma care based on neuroscientific evidence
2023, International Journal of Clinical and Health PsychologyPrognosis of consciousness disorders in the intensive care unit
2023, Presse MedicaleCerebral Glucose Metabolism in Patients with Chronic Disorders of Consciousness
2023, Canadian Journal of Neurological Sciences
- †
Contributed equally to the study