Article Text

PDF

Barré-Liéou “syndrome”
  1. J M S Pearce
  1. 304 Beverley Road, Anlaby, Hull HU10 7BG, UK; jmspearcefreenet.co.uk

    Statistics from Altmetric.com

    Sometimes, non-entities are instructive. Barré’s name is commemorated in the Guillain-Barré eponym,1 but unfortunately, also in the contentious Barré-Liéou syndrome.2,3 Barré described a syndrome of the posterior cervical sympathetic nerves and its frequent cause—chronic cervical arthritis. Barré-Liéou syndrome has the synonyms brachialgia paraesthetica nocturna, cervical migraine, chronic cervical arthritis, migraine cervicale, neurovertebral dystonia, syndrome sympathique cervicale postérieur,4 and vertigo of cervical arthrosis. The number of synonyms appears to be inversely related to the soundness of the diagnosis.

    It has not been agreed as a neurological entity, but is used as a repository for undiagnosed symptoms including those succeeding acute neck injuries, despite the term chronic originally described. Symptoms alleged5,6 are occipital headaches,7 nystagmus on head movement, tinnitus, spasms, blurred vision, corneal hyperaesthesia, and corneal ulcers. Other symptoms (Neri) are anxiety, depression, and memory and cognitive disorders.8 This non-specific constellation has been ascribed to trauma or arthritis of the third and fourth cervical vertebrae or disks, which in turn cause a disturbance of the cervical sympathetic nerves and disordered circulation,2,3 in the cranial nuclei V and V111.

    Much of the literature predates 1990 and appears in journals of chiropraxis, acupuncture, and manipulation (references available from the author). Although the validity of Barré-Liéou syndrome is not generally accepted,9 the term still appears in the literature. Yang Choen Liéou3 described a sympathetic disorder associated with cervical “arthritis” in his thesis of 1928. The Bärtschi-Rochaix syndrome is very similar and of equally dubious substance.

    Jean Alexandre Barré (1880–1967) was born in Nantes and died in Strasbourg.10 He is well known for his work with Guillain on inflammatory polyneuritis (1916). Barré was an intern with Babinski and in 1912 published his thesis on Les ostéoarthropathies du tabes. He met Guillain in the first world war at the centre neurologique of the 6th army. There he served with an ambulance unit caring for patients with major injuries, with outstanding bravery and skill, acknowledged by the Légion d’Honneur, France’s most important military distinction. Because France reoccupied Alsace-Lorraine at the end of the war, a chair was needed in Strasbourg. On his return from the front he was appointed Professor of Neurology in Strasbourg, at that time unique because only in Paris was such a chair extant.1,10

    His interests were also in neuro-otology and vestibular syndromes, and he founded Revue d’Oto-Neuro-Ophthalmologie. He was also preoccupied by semiotics, an interest probably stimulated by Babinski.

    In world war two, Barré rejoined the army but was sent to Clermont-Ferrand in the free zone, “Vichy-France”, seat of the new government. Barré retired in 1950 and sadly suffered a stroke, which left him dysphasic.1,10

    REFERENCES

    View Abstract

    Request permissions

    If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.